Today's political briefing:
Key developments and analysis for Utah policymakers

Utah Policy Daily is a free newsletter published business days by Utah Policy.com. Send us your comments and ideas. See our Policy Daily Archive. Please forward this to friends.

Subscribe or Unsubscribe


Message Center
(Links to Advertisements, Advertorials, Sponsored Articles, and Client Advocacy Essays published to defray the cost of producing Utah Policy Daily.)
Sponsored Article: What do real taxpayers think about HJR1? Ask the Utah Taxpayers Association.

News Highlights

Gov. Jon Huntsman to fight toxic gas shipment (Salt Lake Tribune).

Tribune editorial argues for broad tax reform, not just elimination of corporate income tax.

Smoking bill barely passes in the Senate (Standard-Examiner, Deseret Morning News, Tribune); critics say it goes too far (Daily Herald).

Columnist Bob Bernick says the Legislature is looking for reasons to get along with Gov. Huntsman (Morning News).


Quote of the Day

"Am I afraid? Yes. Is there anywhere else to turn? No. Our option is to call the police."

-- Sharon Neilson, mother of an autistic 18-year-old, who is awaiting state aid (Morning News).


Friday Buzz
Compiled and Written by LaVarr Webb

Well, it’s been a long week. Legislators deserve a couple of days off before hitting the issues again on Monday. Serving in Utah’s Legislature is difficult because the 45-day period the lawmakers are in session is so intense and draining. Lawmakers need to go home, mingle with real people, and recharge for the fights ahead.


Leadership Really Does Matter

Pres. George Bush has been getting a great deal of media coverage lately related to leadership. All of the major newspapers and news magazines have done in-depth articles that focus on his strong leadership. Some of the writers and people quoted obviously believe Bush is leading the country in the wrong direction, but he receives high marks for being willing to take on enormous initiatives (like spreading freedom throughout the world and restructuring Social Security) and pushing them fearlessly against almost insurmountable odds. He is being called a “revolutionary.”

Just proposing big initiatives isn’t enough. Bush’s place in history will depend on how successful he is. Remember that Bill and Hillary Clinton set out to revamp the country’s entire health care system. They failed, and that big initiative is barely a footnote in history.

In Utah, legislators and Gov. Huntsman also have opportunities for revolutionary leadership Probably the two biggest, most visionary, most ambitious (and, by far, most expensive) Big Ideas facing lawmakers this session -- and requiring the most real leadership -- are the balanced transportation initiative and the Strategic Research & Development Initiative being promoted by the Salt Lake Chamber, among other organizations.

These are initiatives that could have transforming impacts on Utah’s economy and future. The transportation initiative would attack gridlock and provide mobility across the Wasatch Front as Utah’s population booms. Projects expected to be constructed over 20 years would be built in just 10 years, including a near-complete system of light rail, commuter rail and bus rapid transit for the Wasatch Front. That’s a Big Idea that requires real leadership.

The Strategic Research & Development Initiative is also a Big Idea that top business leaders believe could be the most important economic development tool in our generation. Tomorrow’s high-paying jobs are dependent on new businesses and industries being developed in exciting new areas of science and technology.

Big Ideas are always difficult and expensive. They always take real leadership to push them to fruition. A number of people, including legislators, are stepping up to find ways to make these two Big Ideas happen. Leadership requires more than simply being visionary. It also requires great political and organizational skills. It requires risk-taking and being persuasive. It requires spending one’s political capital.

We’ll see just how much leadership Utah’s legislators and governor are willing to provide on these two Big Ideas.


Blogger Insights on HJR1

Rep. Steve Urquhart has a thoughtful blog entry on the House debate on HJR1, which the credit unions have targeted with a massive media campaign. “That one side or the other would promise sure political death over a vote on this one issue doesn't cause me to lose any sleep,” Urquhart wrote. “It just disgusts me that special interests could believe (maybe rightly) that they have such power over the political process.”

Speaking of Blogs, some interesting postings on the blog supporting construction of the Legacy Highway. Check it out at: http://legacyhotsheet.blogspot.com.


Perspective on Criticism
“Before you criticize someone, walk a mile in their shoes. That way, when you criticize them, you’re a mile away and you have their shoes.” (Source: Davis County Library newsletter)


Reader Response

Utah Policy Daily recently did a survey of state legislators to see if they are reading the newsletter and what they think of it. We learned that some two-thirds of legislators read the newsletter and most said they greatly appreciate the service. Here are some comments:

“Very Helpful.”
“I am excited to receive your daily report. Thanks for your efforts.”
“It is a huge help to me, especially during the session.”
“I read the newspapers but make sure I don’t miss anything by reading your Utah Policy Daily.”
“I very much appreciate the convenience of Utah Policy Daily. Very helpful, comfortable format. Thank you very much.”
“Thank you! The Utah Policy Daily is a valuable resource. I read it daily. Thank you.”
“Thank you. I faithfully read and look forward to your daily updates.”
“I find your email very useful and informative as it relates to public policy. Thank you!”
“I enjoy the information and check it out daily. I appreciate the news articles in an easy place to review. I have thought several times that I should say thanks. I get a lot of mail/junkmail. Utah Policy is one I always open.”
“Great job! I find it very useful. Thanks.”
“I read over it and hit at least a few articles briefly every day.”
“Very good information. Thank you.”
“I find it very helpful and informative. Thanks.”
“I enjoy the newsletter. It keeps me abreast of issues that impact the state and my district.”
“Keep up the good work. I enjoy the information.”


Quotes on Politics

“To avoid criticism do nothing, say nothing, be nothing.”
--Elbert Hubbard

"If two men agree on everything, you may be sure that only one of them is doing the thinking."
--Lyndon B. Johnson

"Whenever a fellow tells me he is bipartisan I know he is going to vote against me." --Harry Truman

“Mothers all want their sons to grow up to be president but they don't want them to become politicians in the process.” --John Fitzgerald Kennedy


 

Friday
January 28, 2005

Salt Lake Tribune
- White Mesa Utes cry 'environmental racism'
- Rolly: Getting auditors' numbers
- Governor to fight toxic gas shipment
- Smoking ban for bars barely flickers in Senate
- Playing hardball with higher ed
- GOP caucus approves post-flood loan plan
- Patient bill gaining momentum
- No paper trails?
- New legislator steps in
- Resolution opposes NAFTA-like pact
- Bill to broaden auditor's power passes
- Lawmaker backs off ban on school district police
- Editorial: Wing and a prayer

Standard-Examiner
- Smoking bill squeaks through to Senate floor

KSL Editorial Board
- The Legislature online

Daily Herald
- Senate pushes insurance reform forward
- Critics say smoking ban bill goes to far
- New bill for tuition tax credits unveiled in House
- Residents plea for money for human services
- Op-ed: Credits offer more parental involvement, greater savings
- Op-ed: Utah cannot afford to 'try' tuition tax credits
- Op-ed: Rebuttal to M. Royce Van Tassell
- Op-ed: Rebuttal to Linnea S. Barney
- Editorial: The worth of tuition tax credits

Deseret Morning News
- Smoking ban advances after a fiery debate
-
2 counties sue over grazing
-
Utah leaders adamant on blocking toxic waste
-
Local mental health centers feeling effects of funding cuts
-
Medical choice bill could lower — or raise — costs
- Up to 19% tuition hike is possible
-
Envision Utah selects Huntsman as co-chair

- Bob Bernick Jr.: Cooperative spirit reigns on Hill — for now


Sponsored Article
Taxpayers Association Supports HJR1

The Utah Taxpayers Association is Utah’s independent tax watchdog. It almost always opposes higher taxes and it believes government should be limited and lean. So how does the Association feel about taxing big credit unions?

Good question, and readily answered. The Association carefully studied the issue of credit union taxation and came to the common sense conclusion rather easily that the large credit unions that have abandoned the traditional role of credit unions should be taxed like other financial institutions on their profits not returned to members. You can read the Taxpayers Association’s position on credit union taxation at its Web site, www.utahtaxpayers.org. Click on Special Reports in the left-hand navigation bar and then scroll down to “Credit Union Taxation in Utah” and click on that report. Here’s the 12-page report’s conclusion:

“The Utah Taxpayers Association believes it is incumbent upon the Utah Legislature and Congress to re-establish equity between credit unions and taxable financial institutions. The competitive activity of credit unions must be limited, or they must be subject to the same state and federal tax obligations as their taxable competitors.”

With regard to HJR1, currently before the Utah Senate, the Taxpayers Association urges legislators to: “Please vote YES on HJR1.” (Go to www.utahtaxpayers.org and click on “View Position Papers.”) “HJR 1 urges Congress to provide a principled, fair, and equitable tax structure for financial institutions that allows the state to determine what state and local taxes shall apply to financial institutions. Inequitable tax treatment distorts economic decision-making in the free market and places one taxpayer at a government-sanctioned advantage over another,” the Association says.

In another position paper at the same location on the Web site, the Association refutes a credit union mailer distributed to thousands of Utahns, saying the mailer made factual errors in interpreting tax laws and in attacking Zions Bank’s activities in Nevada.

(Sponsored by The Exoro Group)


Political Calendar

Please submit calendar items to Daily@UtahPolicy.com
- Jan 29: Republican Central Committee Meeting, 9 am, State Capitol.
- Jan 31: Utah Issues 31st Citizen's Day at the Legislature, 8:30am to 1:30 pm, Prime Hotel, 215 W South Temple, Salt Lake City. Free event with breakfast and lunch provided. For more information please visit www.utahissues.org.
- Feb 3: Salt Lake Chamber's Annual Legislative Reception, 5:30 pm to 8 pm, Grand America Hotel.
- Feb 5: Annual Green Party of Utah Convention, 10 am to 2 pm, Anderson-Foothill Library, 1135 E 2100 S, Salt Lake City.
- Feb 12: Morgan County Lincoln Day Dinner.
- Feb 12: Utah County Lincoln Day Dinner.
- Feb 18: Last day for legislators to prioritize bills and other programs with fiscal impact.
- Feb 23: Final meeting for the Executive Appropriations Committee on all budget matters.
- Feb 25: Massachusetts Gov. and 2008 presidential hopeful Mitt Romney speaks at Salt Lake County Republican Lincoln Day Dinner, 7 p.m., Little America Hotel. For ticket information see: www.lincolnclub.net.
- Feb 25: Bonding bill available to legislators by noon and final action taken on it by calendared closing time.
- Feb 25: Last day to pass bills with fiscal note of $10,000 or more.
- Feb 26: Republican Women Federation Fundraiser.
- Feb 27: Last day to consider bills from own house.
- Feb 27: Last day for a motion to reconsider.
- Feb 28: General appropriations bill, supplemental appropriations bill, and school finance bill available to legislators by calendared floor time and final action taken on each bill by calendared closing time.
- Mar 2: Second supplemental appropriations bill available to legislators by calendared floor time and final action taken by noon.
- Mar 2:  2005 legislative session ends.
- Mar 22: Last day governor may sign or veto bills.
- Apr 30: Utah County Republican Party Organizing Convention, 7 pm, Canyon View Junior High, 950 N 700 E, Orem.
- May 1: Last day a veto-override session may begin.
- May 2: Normal effective date for bills.
- May 2: First day to file bills for the 2006 General Session.

- See the entire calendar

Elected Officials Birthday List


Utah Policy Daily is a service
of Utah Policy.com

Publisher: LaVarr Webb
Editor: Paul Hollingshead
News: Golden Webb
Calendar and Subscriptions: Luci Webb