Today's political briefing:
Key developments and analysis for Utah policymakers

Utah Policy Daily is a free newsletter published business days by Utah Policy.com. Send us your comments and ideas. See our Policy Daily Archive. Please forward this to friends.

Subscribe or Unsubscribe


Message Center

(Links to Advertisements, Advertorials, Sponsored Articles, and Client Advocacy Essays published to defray the cost of producing Utah Policy Daily.)
  • Big credit unions say taxes are “unfortunate,” feeding “the beast of inefficient government.”

  • News Highlights
    Hate crimes bill voted down for 10th straight time (Deseret Morning News, Daily Herald and Salt Lake Tribune).

    Democrats back Gov. Jon Huntsman on lower level of transportation funding (Morning News): Transportation is still a sticking point in House/Senate agreement on budget (Tribune).

    Utah County abruptly leaves the Mountainland Association of Governments (Tribune, Daily Herald and Morning News).

    Rep. Jim Ferrin scales back tuition tax bill to reduce budget impact (Tribune and Morning News).


    Quote of the Day
    “Ironically, the only reform bill that has a chance is the one Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr. is pushing, which would reform practices in the executive branch only, as well as enact term limits on governors.”

    -- Morning News editorial on ethics reform.


    Wednesday Buzz
    Compiled and Written by LaVarr Webb

    Tribune Highlights Blogging
    Utah’s mainstream news media are finally paying attention to the phenomenon of local political blogging. Thomas Burr, a Tribune reporter did a nice story today on Rep. Steve Urquhart’s foray into blogging, and notes that more Republican political blogs are coming. Urquhart is quoted as saying: "Because the session gets so busy, the blog is a wonderful way to communicate with constituents."

    Media Watch: The Convergence Project
    The Deseret Morning News/KSL TV-Radio convergence experiment seems to be moving ahead, slowly but surely. We’re seeing newspaper reporters appear more frequently on television and radio, and broadcast reporters write for the newspaper. KSL Radio’s Russ Hill, for example, wrote an in-depth piece for the newspaper on his trip to Banda Aceh with a tsunami relief group.

    With a common owner in the LDS Church, it makes sense for KSL TV-Radio and the Morning News to collaborate. More reporting and editing resources can be brought to bear on breaking news and in-depth coverage. Mass communications has all gone digital, so the idea is to use the reporting, editing, still and video photography capabilities of all three entities and deliver news and information in whatever format is desired by readers, viewers and listeners, whether print, video, audio or on-line.

    Interestingly, while it would seem that collaboration on their Web sites would be the most natural and easiest place to start, we have yet to see much Web convergence. The Morning News site has a link to KSL, but I couldn’t even find a link to the newspaper on the KSL home page. It would really make sense to simply combine the newspaper and broadcast Web sites. Think how cool it would be to go to KSLMorningNews.com and be able to read an in-depth story, and click on audio and video coverage of the same event.

    Most likely, it’s the advertising side of the business that prevents Web collaboration. The Newspaper Agency Corporation sells and places Web advertising for both the Morning News and Tribune, while KSL has its own advertising operation. So trying to make a combined Morning News/KSL site accommodate advertising sold for both newspapers would get awkward. At any rate, the convergence of print and broadcast is an interesting and worthwhile endeavor.

    Communications Tip:
    Key Audiences for Politicians

    Let’s say you’re a Utah House member and you want to win re-election in 2006. Who should you be communicating with to ensure a successful race? Here are three key audiences:

    • Opinion leaders in your district. These are the most influential people in your district, the mayors, city council members, business leaders, and key ecclesiastical leaders. You should communicate with them frequently by visits, phone calls, and letters. You should maintain an updated list of them and make sure you stay in touch. These are the people who will be highly influential in your next election.
    • Political activists. These are state and county party delegates, people who attend party caucuses, and grassroots party people. This is also a crucially important audience. You should be communicating with these people through letters, print or e-mail newsletters, town meetings, and reports to constituents.
    • Active voters. Don’t waste time with people who don’t vote. Focus on active voters. If you don’t have lists of the most active voters in your district, contact Xi Corporation at www.exoroinfo.com. While communication with active voters doesn’t need to be as frequent as with the first two audiences, you ought to be touching them at least a couple of times a year, preferably quarterly. Use newsletters or a report to constituents letter to get to them.

    Many politicians win an election and then forget about communicating with constituents until the next election. That’s a big mistake. Some politicians think they will be bothering constituents if they communicate too much. That’s also a big mistake. I guarantee your constituents won’t feel like you’re bugging them. In fact, they will feel special because you are communicating with them. In today’s oversaturated communications world where they are seeing the same TV commercial dozens of times, a quarterly communication from you won’t seem like much at all.


    Sponsored Article
    Mega-credit unions show true colors on taxation

    By LaVarr Webb
         Utah’s billion dollar credit unions apparently share the anti-tax, anti-government, and anti-public education philosophy of right-wing activist Grover Norquist.

         Their philosophy was perfectly displayed in an e-mail newsletter disseminated Tuesday by the Utah League of Credit Unions. The big credit unions trotted out Norquist, president of Americans for Tax Reform, to say this: "Taxes are unfortunate. They feed the beast of inefficient government, and they place ever higher burdens on families and businesses. They make society less wealthy, and people less free.”

         What a simplistic approach to taxation Norquist and these billion-dollar credit unions take: Taxes are “unfortunate.” Therefore, mega-credit unions shouldn't have to pay them.

         It might come as a surprise to Utah’s education and local government leaders to learn that Utah’s big credit unions believe they are beasts of inefficiency that reduce people’s freedom. Thanks to this e-mail newsletter, Utah’s school and local government leaders now understand the attitude of the big credit unions toward them and the taxes that support their missions. The selection of Norquist as credit union spokesperson shows their true colors.

         It’s interesting how Utah’s mega-credit unions rely on a workforce educated in our public schools. But they don’t want to help pay for those schools. They use our streets and water and police and fire services. But they are proud that they don’t pay sales taxes that help fund these services. They don’t want to pay what they consider “unfortunate” taxes that “feed the beast of inefficient government.”

         It’s also interesting to contrast the attitude of Norquist and the big credit unions with the philosophy of the Utah Taxpayers Association, which is the real representative of business and individual taxpayers in Utah. The Taxpayers Association advocates low taxes and limited government, but also fights for fair, equitable, balanced taxation. The Association strongly advocates that the big credit unions pay their fair share of income and sales taxes to support public needs like education and local government. (Read the Association’s report on credit union taxation by going to www.utahtaxpayers.org, clicking on Special Reports, and scrolling down to the report.)

         That’s why this fight is not longer just between the big credit unions and the banks. Small business owners and organizations like the Taxpayers Association want low tax rates spread across all large and profitable businesses that cannot justify a tax exemption. Education leaders and local government officials are concerned about the tax base erosion caused by the billion dollar credit unions as they grow aggressively, retain millions of dollars in profits not distributed to members, and take more and more economic activity off the tax rolls.

         In contrast to the big credit unions, Utah’s banks, according to the legislative fiscal analyst, will pay $50 million in “unfortunate” income taxes to support Utah’s schools over two years, more millions in “unfortunate” sales taxes, and hundreds of millions more in “unfortunate” federal taxes to support our military, homeland security, to protect the environment, and all the other things government does.

         In the credit union newsletter, Norquist said Utah's passage of HJR1 might serve as a "potential model for other states.” He is absolutely right, which is all the more reason to pass the resolution. What Utah is doing could spread. That’s the great value of HJR1. It has no force of law. It doesn’t raise anyone’s taxes. But symbolically it is incredibly powerful. It means one state is standing up to the political pressure and the misleading million-dollar advertising blitz of the wealthy credit unions, and is saying, “This isn’t right. Congress needs to act.”

         The message to Congress is pretty simple: Let the small, traditional credit unions retain their tax exemption. But do something about the billion-dollar credit unions that want to expand aggressively, make large commercial loans, and do everything tax-paying institutions can do, without contributing their fair share to schools and local governments.

         (Sponsored by the Exoro Group)


     

     

    Wednesday
    February 9, 2005

    Seattle Times
    -
    E.J. Dionne Jr.: The GOP's bait-and-switch on the Gonzales nomination

    Deseret Morning News
    - Ure puts a cork in liquor issue
    -
    Hate-crimes bill suffers 10th defeat
    -
    School boards may ditch 'prayer'
    -
    Testimony against Workman rebutted
    -
    County no longer in MAG
    -
    Legislators try to keep Hill AFB viable
    -
    Demos back governor on transportation funds

    - Measure aims at religious protesters
    -
    Revised tuition tax credits bill would aid only poorest students
    -
    More study ordered for tax measure

    - Provider law pits patient access against costs
    -
    Measure to thwart Rocky stalls in Senate
    -
    Midwife legislation passes in close vote
    -
    Charter schools bill sails out of committee
    -
    Panel favors increase in statute of limitations
    - Credit union resolution finally goes to panel
    -
    Hale chosen to replace Julander as manager
    -
    Editorial: A woeful ethics reform record

    Daily Herald

    - Hate crimes bill dies in committee
    - Utah County to leave area association of governments
    - Editorial: Keep the County Commission in the loop

    St. George Spectrum
    - Legislature cuts funding for sexual evaluations

    Salt Lake Tribune
    -
    Witness tells a different story

    - Divorce proposal heads to counseling
    -
    Stadium tricky goal for SLC, says mayor
    -
    Court ships wilds suit back to Utah
    -
    No full debate for hate crimes bill
    -
    Utah County votes to bolt Mountainland association
    -
    Proposal could void Utah driver license as ID
    -
    Mayor steals SLC Council hopeful's thunder
    -
    Battle looms over funds for commuter rail
    -
    Bill scales back tuition tax break
    -
    Roads cause budget gridlock
    -
    Bill aimed at freedom of doctor choice
    -
    Education: No yearly limits would be set on how many new such schools the panel allows
    -
    House seeks more control over state Capitol
    -
    Lawmaker-blogger keeps constituents up to date
    -
    Editorial: Budget brinkmanship


    Political Calendar

    Please submit calendar items to Daily@UtahPolicy.com

    - Feb 12: Morgan County Lincoln Day Dinner.
    - Feb 12: Utah County Lincoln Day Dinner.

    - Feb 12:  Davis County Democrats “No Host” breakfast/monthly food drive, 8:30 am, Grannie Annie’s restaurant, 286 N 400 W, Kaysville.  The public is invited and everyone is asked to bring a non-perishable food item to benefit the food banks in Davis County.
    - Feb 16: Voice for Moderation meeting, 6 pm to 7:30 pm, Anderson/Foothill Library.  Guest speakers Jay Blain, a Granite School Administrator, and Dave Gessel, VP Utah Hospital Association, will discuss educational and medical issues being debated by the legislature. 
    - Feb 18: Last day for legislators to prioritize bills and other programs with fiscal impact.
    - Feb 23: Final meeting for the Executive Appropriations Committee on all budget matters.
    - Feb 25: Massachusetts Gov. and 2008 presidential hopeful Mitt Romney speaks at Salt Lake County Republican Lincoln Day Dinner, 7 pm, Little America Hotel. For ticket information see: www.lincolnclub.net.
    - Feb 25:  Salt Lake County Lincoln Day Dinner.
    - Feb 25: Bonding bill available to legislators by noon and final action taken on it by calendared closing time.
    - Feb 25: Last day to pass bills with fiscal note of $10,000 or more.
    - Feb 27: Last day to consider bills from own house.
    - Feb 27: Last day for a motion to reconsider.
    - Feb 28: General appropriations bill, supplemental appropriations bill, and school finance bill available to legislators by calendared floor time and final action taken on each bill by calendared closing time.
    - Mar 2: Second supplemental appropriations bill available to legislators by calendared floor time and final action taken by noon.
    - Mar 2:  2005 legislative session ends.
    - Mar 12:  Davis County Democrats “No Host” breakfast/monthly food drive, 8:30 am, Grannie Annie’s restaurant, 286 N 400 W, Kaysville.  The public is invited and everyone is asked to bring a non-perishable food item to benefit the food banks in Davis County.
    - Mar 22:  Last day governor may sign or veto bills.
    - Mar 26:  Republican Women Federation Fundraiser and Auction, "Heroes of the Heart,"  5:30 pm, McKay Events Center, UVSC, Provo.  Speakers: First Lady Mary Kaye Huntsman and Sen. Orrin Hatch.  For more information, please contact Suzanne Merrill - 801-796-0831.
    - Apr 9:  Davis County Democratic Party Organizing Convention, 11 am, Farmington Jr. High School,150 S. 200 West, Farmington.
    - Apr 30: Utah County Republican Party Organizing Convention, 7 pm, Canyon View Junior High, 950 N 700 E, Orem.
    - May 1: Last day a veto-override session may begin.
    - May 2: Normal effective date for bills.
    - May 2: First day to file bills for the 2006 General Session.
    - May 14:  Davis County Democrats “No Host” breakfast/monthly food drive, 8:30 am, Grannie Annie’s restaurant, 286 N 400 W, Kaysville.  The public is invited and everyone is asked to bring a non-perishable food item to benefit the food banks in Davis County.

    - See the entire calendar

    Elected Officials Birthday List


    Utah Policy Daily is a service
    of Utah Policy.com

    Publisher: LaVarr Webb
    Editor: Paul Hollingshead
    News: Golden Webb
    Calendar and Subscriptions: Luci Webb