Today's political briefing: Key developments
and analysis for Utah policymakers

Utah Policy Daily is a free newsletter published
business days by Utah Policy.com. Send us your
comments and ideas
. See our Policy Daily Archive.
Please forward this to friends.

Subscribe or Unsubscribe


Message Center
(Links to Advertisements, Advertorials, Sponsored Articles, and Client Advocacy Essays.)

Another Question for Readers

We're always trying to improve Utah Policy Daily and it really helps to receive feedback from readers. This question has to do with the local headline links in the right column. Currently, we simply publish the story headline with the link embedded. Once in a while the headline doesn't provide much clue about the substance of the story. Our goal is to provide enough information so readers can glance through the political stories and decide what they want to click on. So here's the question: Would it be helpful if we added another sentence about each story? That would make the list of headline links longer, but provide more information. The story link would look something like:

Corroon tweaks budget Mayor proposes $11 million in cuts, restructuring administration.

Please send me a quick e-mail at daily@utahpolicy.com and tell me if you'd prefer the extra info or if our current system works just fine.


News Highlights

ACLU, bookstores, artists, and Internet service providers to sue Utah over anti-porn law (Deseret Morning News, Daily Herald and Salt Lake Tribune). (See also National Media Watch).

Utah Wildlife Board: Wolves welcome in Utah, but will be shot if they threaten livestock (Tribune, Standard-Examiner, and Morning News).

Salt Lake County Councilman David Wilde to run for mayor of Murray city (Morning News).


Quote of the Day

“These 15 folks have this in store: They will work long hours over this summer and the fall trying to figure out the best way to reform Utah's long-standing — some would say antiquated — tax system. And when they finish it all, most likely they'll just see criticism and complaints; the whole Legislature is going to tear it apart. In the end, they'll even see their work product kicked around in newspapers and on TV.”

-- Political Columnist Bob Bernick, writing about the Tax Reform Task Force and how hard it is to truly reform taxes (Morning News).


Friday Buzz
Written by LaVarr Webb & Associates

Alert: Rainy Weekend
The Scott Matheson-intoned flood watchcry of 1983 remains valid 22 years later: This really is “a helluva way to run a desert.” Given the massive snowpack statewide and the ultra-rainy spring, it’s amazing we’ve weathered the spring flooding as well as we have. It’s no solace to those relatively few who did get wet, but the snowpack came down in about as orderly a fashion as was possible. So as the pitter-patter of rain ruins our weekend, we ought to be grateful it’s not a whole lot worse.

Tax Watch
Utah Foundation Research
As a legislative task force charged with overhauling Utah's tax system looks into instituting a flat income tax it is worth looking back at an analysis of the flat tax done by the Utah Foundation back in February. Analysts looked at the six states with a flat state income tax -- Colorado, Illinois, Indiana, Massachusetts, Michigan and Pennsylvania -- and studied how their budgets were effected post-9/11.

Among the conclusions: "Broad-based flat income taxes, like those in Pennsylvania, Indiana, and Illinois, do appear to be more stable, providing revenues that do not suffer declines as severe as other states during recessions. The tradeoff that comes with greater stability, however, is slower revenue growth during positive economic cycles. Slower growth may be desirable to those who prefer to limit government growth, but because of the income tax’s tie to education funding in Utah, slower growth may be undesirable to those looking for greater increases in education funding during economic expansion years. In addition, a flat income tax carries less opportunity to craft a progressive tax system that eases burdens on low-income taxpayers." -- Golden Webb

UTA Recommendations
Utah Taxpayer Association (UTA) leaders were a little miffed that media coverage of the recent Tax Reform Task Force meeting indicated that some of those testifying didn’t offer concrete recommendations on tax reform. While time didn’t allow every item in Utah’s state and local tax structure to be addressed, the UTA was specific in its recommendations on several major tax issues. A UTA position paper on tax reform, which will be updated as the tax reform process moves along, can be found on the association Web site.

New School Choice Leader
Mike Jerman, Utah Taxpayer Association vice president, has been named chair of two related school choice organizations: Parents for Choice in Education, a 501(c)(4) corporation, and Parents for Choice in Education PAC.

Jerman, who is also vice president of the Utah Taxpayers Association, has long been a supporter of school choice. He said he is honored to serve as chair, a voluntary position. “Parental choice is essential to ensuring that every Utah child has a quality education, and now is the time to make it a reality,” he said. Doug Holmes, the previous chair, will continue to be involved in the school choice movement.

Blog Watch
-- Does God help entrepreneurs? Read Paul Allen’s provocative comments.

-- Wilf Sommerkorn weighs in on the fight between North Salt Lake and Salt Lake City over foothill property that some want to develop and others want to preserve as open space.

Media Watch
Strong Feelings About Talk Radio
Thanks to all of you who responded to my invitation to comment on talk radio. I have seven pages of comments and they keep coming. I’ll publish some of them over the next few editions and provide a link to all of them. I was a little surprised at the intensity of feeling and the divergent opinions. Lots of you don’t like the highly-partisan talk show hosts, despite the popularity of some of them in this radio market. I suppose it demonstrates the superior intellect and clear thinking of Utah Policy Daily readers.

Some of you, including my friend Rep. Pat Jones, scolded me for admitting that I sometimes listen to Sean Hannity and Bill O’Reilly: “Didn't you learn in church that if you hang out with the bad crowd, it rubs off on you? Why, then, do you listen to people who preach hate? Just a thought.”

Ron Barney: Here’s an unpopular notion. The frenzy and clamor for current events and titillating intrigue, which is the basis for talk radio, has created a cultural corpus so top-heavy with the here-and-now that historical perspective is rarely melded into our societal discussions, rendering the atmosphere-of-opinion stunted, skewed, and polemical. That you have resolved to consider Rush O’Hannity “entertainment” is an indicator that you, too, are inordinately weighted toward this incredibly discordant aspect of public dialogue. (The argument is no different if Al Franken and Jon Stewart are the summary of your daily consumption.) Of course people are interested in the “breaking news” of public interest. But our shameless neglect of where we have been in order to inform where we are now makes the polemical, divisive talk radio you have accommodated less than beneficial. We don’t need an hour of Franken following Hannity. We need a David McCullough or Doris Kearns Goodwin involved in our public discussions, even though it might not be “entertaining.” If entertainment becomes the arbiter of public thought, the flush we hear in the background will become more vivid.

Mark Fotheringham: I have difficulty listening to anyone who engages in what I like to call the "politics of outrage." I enjoy the search for truth and understanding that comes with informed and polite dialogue, but the ranting hosts of most talk radio shows seem more interested in seeing whose pot we can get to boil today, rather than in a sincere search for truth. That is why, even though I consider myself mostly conservative, I can listen to NPR for an entire afternoon, but the so called "entertainers" you mentioned will get the OFF button at about three seconds. Silence is better than bozos.

Todd Weiler (Davis County GOP chair): I think talk radio is a great form of entertainment. I get a little worried about the people who cannot distinguish "entertainment" from "news". Fourteen years ago (when I lived in L.A.) I enjoyed listening to Dr. Laura and Rush. I have a hard time listening to either one of them today -- especially Dr. Laura. I can only listen to Michael Savage in small snippets. He is a bit too mean-spirited for my taste. Lars Larsen is probably the best of the up-and-comers.

Casual Friday
What To Do In The Rain
The Downtown Farmers' Market starts Saturday at Pioneer Park, 300 South 300 West. The market features fresh produce from over 50 Utah farmers. In addition to produce, the market also offers a variety of fresh baked breads and pastries, cheeses, meat and seafood, jams and honeys, house and garden plants, arranged planters, and numerous handmade arts & crafts. Unique food vendors also are a part of the Market, offering prepared foods and beverages.

The Downtown Alliance Web site has more information about the Farmers’ Market and also a 16-page guide to summer activities downtown.

Late Night Jokes
Jay Leno.... Deep Throat was the biggest mystery in Washington since how the Clintons stayed together. .... The Deep Throat incident was about the Watergate break in, when the Republicans broke into the Watergate hotel to see what the Democrats were up to. You see, back in those days the Democrats actually had ideas worth stealing. .... Did you hear about this? Up at the Canadian border they let a hitchhiker cross into Maine carrying a homemade sword, a hatchet, a knife, brass knuckles and a chainsaw stained by blood. It was Howard Dean. . . . According to "Sports Illustrated”, a winery is coming out with a NASCAR wine. Which will finally answer the question, which wine goes with chili corn dogs?

Conan . . . If Michael Jackson is convicted he could end up in the same prison as Charles Manson. Charles Manson heard this and said, "I hope not, that guy is nuts.” . . . According to Michael Jackson’s father, Joe, if Michael is found guilty he will take care of Michael’s kids. Joe Jackson went on to say, "I might be old, but I can still dangle kids from a balcony.”


 

Friday
June 10, 2005

National Media Watch
Utah ACLU to challenge new porn blocking law; claims controversial legislation violates state residents' rights to free expression and unlawfully interferes with interstate commerce (CNET News and Associated Press).

Local Headlines
Salt Lake City Weekly
- Contract critical

Deseret Morning News

- New cities eat county tax base

- Regents look to future

- Suit challenges Utah's anti-porn law

- Plaintiffs' arguments against Utah's anti-pornography law

- Scholarship honors Walker

- S.L. Council questions water plan

- Wolf compromise adopted by board

- Dixie Forest deal pleases managers, wilds activists

- Salt Lake County councilman to run for Murray mayor's seat

- Utahns urged to help lure businesses

- Bob Bernick Jr.: Major tax reform is a tough political pill to take

- Editorial: Hurray for Utah's new court

Standard-Examiner

- Clinton to rework sex-offender ban

- Wolves lose key decision

Daily Herald

- Task force pushes flat income tax

- ACLU to challenge porn law

- Editorial: Trouble looms for Amendment 3

St. George Spectrum

- Council approves tentative budget

- Nearly $63 million released for flood damage mitigation

Salt Lake Tribune

- Council restricts monster remodels

- Jerman new head of school choice group

- Bill would benefit Utah's public lands, enviro projects

- Group: Utah Web porn law unconstitutional, too broad

- Utah part of oil shale project

- Senate to move ahead on Griffith confirmation

- Family ties may be conflict for official

- Can ranchers, wolves get along?
- Advocates for needy support IHC at legislative task force meeting


Political Calendar

Please submit calendar items to Daily@UtahPolicy.com

- June 10: Annual Reagan Memorial Picnic sponsored by the Davis County Republican Party and the Teenage Republicans, 6 pm, Layton Commons Park Bowery, 465 North Wasatch Drive, Layton. Special guest speaker Doug Wright. For more information email Kathy Wilson at missionparis@comcast.net.
- June 11: Davis County Democrats “No Host” breakfast/monthly food drive, 8:30 am, Grannie Annie’s restaurant, 286 N 400 W, Kaysville.  The public is invited and everyone is asked to bring a non-perishable food item to benefit the food banks in Davis County.
- June 11: Salt Lake County Democratic Party Central Committee Meeting, 9 am to 11 am, Salt Lake County Council Chambers, 2001 S State Street. For more information call the Salt Lake County Democratic Party at 801-220-0122.
- June 12-14: Western Governors’ Association’s Annual Meeting in Breckenridge, Colorado.  Colorado Gov. Bill Owens, WGA Chairman, will be joined by his colleagues, the secretaries of the U.S. departments of energy and agriculture, Western Canadian premiers and economic experts to discuss Western Leadership in the Global Economy.  For more information visit www.westgov.org.
- June 13: State Water Development Commission meeting, 11 am, Room W135.  See Legislative Calendar for more information.
- June 13: Judicial Rules Review Committee, 3 pm, room W020.
- June 14: Legislative task force meetings throughout day.  See calendar to check schedule.
- June 14:  Dan Jones and Associates' 25th anniversary party, 5 pm to 8 pm, Red Butte Garden, 300 Wakara Way, Salt Lake City.

- June 14: Sage Greens Local Meeting, 7 pm, Coffee Club, 4879 South Redwood Road.
- June 15: Legislative Interim Committee Day. Task force meetings throughout day.  See calendar to check schedule.
- June 15: Natural Resources, Agriculture, and Environment Interim Committee meeting, 2 pm, room W125.  See Legislative Calendar for more information.
- June 16: State Rulemaking Seminar, 9 am to 3 pm, 5112 State Office Building.
- June 23: Salt Lake County Libertarian Party Organizing Convention, 7 pm, Rocky Mountain Pizza Company, 3977 Wasatch Boulevard, Holladay.
- June 26: Green Party of Utah Monthly Council Meeting, 10 am, Salt Lake County Government Complex, 2100 South State Street, Salt Lake City.
- June 30: Common Cause of Utah's "Holding Power Accountable" informational forum, 6:30 to 8pm, Salt Lake City main library, Level 1, Room B. The panel includes Jeff Hunt, Attorney for the Freedom of Information Hotline;  Joel Campbell, BYU Assistant Professor of Print Journalism; and Frank Nakamura, Murray City Attorney. Speakers will address issues involved in trying to implement Utah's Government Records Access Management Act.  This program is free and open to the public.  For more information contact Tony Musci at ccause@qwest.net or 801-533-0876.
- July 12: Sage Greens Local Meeting, 7 pm, Coffee Club, 4879 South Redwood Road.
- July 14: 2005 Sutherland Transcend Series,"Civility, Integrity and Politics - Being an Authentic Citizen," breakfast and morning seminar begins at 8:30 am.  For more information contact Lisa Montgomery at 801-355-1272 or email si@sutherlandinstitute.org.
- July 19: Utah House Republicans Third Annual Bowler's Ball, 6:30 pm, Shepherd's All Star Lanes in West Jordan.  Interested parties should contact Kat Dayton at 801-580-4743.
- July 20: Legislative Interim Committee Day.
- July 24: Green Party of Utah Monthly Council Meeting, 10 am, Salt Lake County Government Complex, 2100 South State Street, Salt Lake City.
- July 27-29:  Utah Association of Counties 2005 Recorders Summer Workshop, Cache Administration Building, 179 North Main, Logan. Contact Calleen Peshell for more details at 435-843-3180 or cpeshell@co.tooele.ut.us
- July 29: Filing Deadline for Candidates, Platform Amendments, and Resolution Amendments to the State Organizing Convention, 5 pm.
- Aug 4: Legislative Golf Tournament. Thanksgiving Point at Lehi, Utah
- Aug 11: 2005 Sutherland Transcend Series,"Contours of the Rule of Law - Understanding Legal Frameworks," breakfast and morning seminar begins at 8:30 am.  For more information contact Lisa Montgomery at 801-355-1272 or email si@sutherlandinstitute.org.
- Aug 12: Deadline for Republican County Parties to certify their state delegates to State Party Offices.
- Aug 20: Utah Democratic Party 3rd Quarter State Central Committee, 10 am. Location to be announced.
- Aug 27: Republican State Organizing Convention - Elections held for State Party Officers.
- Sep 9:  Senate Republicans Golf Tournament, 7 am, details to come. 
- Sep 21: Legislative Interim Committee Day.

- See the entire calendar

Elected Officials Birthday List


Utah Policy Daily is a service
of Utah Policy.com

Publisher: LaVarr Webb
Editor: Paul Hollingshead
News: Golden Webb
Calendar and Subscriptions: Luci Webb