Today's political briefing: Key developments
and analysis for Utah policymakers

Utah Policy Daily is a free newsletter published
business days by Utah Policy.com. Send us your
comments and ideas
. See our Policy Daily Archive.
Please forward this to friends.

Subscribe or Unsubscribe


Message Center

(Links to Advertisements, Advertorials, Sponsored Articles, and Client Advocacy Essays.)

Please Take a Quick Survey

As we work to improve the content and delivery of Utah Policy Daily, it would be very helpful for us to know how it is accessed and read. Please take a very quick survey telling us whether you read UPD as an e-mail message on a regular computer, on a PDA like a Blackberry, or on the Web at www.utahpolicy.com.

Take the Survey

Winning at the Legislature

Now is the time to communicate with and educate lawmakers about important issues coming up in the 2006 session. Read more below.

Reach Utah Policymakers

The Exoro Group will soon publish a new edition of the popular Legislative Guide, and is now accepting advertising reservations. The guide is an excellent way to stay visible and deliver your advertising message to Utah opinion leaders and policymakers. Some 5,000 copies of the handy, pocket-sized, 88-page guide will be printed in full color, with color photos and bios of Utah’s 104 state lawmakers, plus committee assignments, seating charts, events calendar, and much more valuable information. For pricing and deadlines, contact Business Development Director Mark Towner, 801.502.9134, mark@utahpolicy.com.


News Highlights

S.L. City Attorney Ed Rutan gave Mayor Rocky Anderson OK to pay meal and room expenses for non-city employees during trip to Torino, Italy (Deseret Morning News and Salt Lake Tribune).

Rematch between Provo Mayor Lewis Billings and challenger Dave Bailey getting testy (Morning News  and Tribune).

Tribune editorial urges Provo School District to adopt policy that allows gay-straight alliance club.

Legislative probe shows criminals among day care workers (Tribune).


Quote of the Day

“’He's handsome, has a full head of hair (Bennett is bald). He's a good speaker; a bright man with a bright image. It's exciting (to Republicans across the nation) that he's governor of Massachusetts’ — long a state that has voted for Democrats for president.”

-- Sen. Bob Bennett, assessing the chances of Mitt Romney to become president, as reported by Political Editor Bob Bernick in his Friday column (Morning News).



Friday Buzz
Written by LaVarr Webb & Associates

Dayton vs. Hellewell?

Rep. Margaret Dayton appears poised to challenge Sen. Parley Hellewell for the District 15 Orem-area State Senate seat next year. It should be an interesting battle. Dayton, who has been Utah’s lead combatant on the No Child Left Behind issue, held a highly successful fundraiser Tuesday night at the “Great Barn” on Geneva Road. My sources said more than 100 people showed up, including Lt. Gov. Gary Herbert, Sen. Orrin Hatch, and a number of state representatives and senators. John Tinsley is among a number of candidates expected to run for Dayton’s House seat. 

Mower is Deputy COS

Congrats to Mike Mower, who has been appointed deputy chief of staff in the Governor’s Office. He will work closely with new Chief of Staff Neil Ashdown. Anna Atwater has been appointed policy coordinate for the governor. See press release.

Utahns Love Mass Transit

An on-line survey conducted by the Lt. Governor's Office on Utah transportation issues produced some interesting results, which will be discussed at today’s Transportation Summit. Among the survey highlights: 89.9% of the more than 1,000 respondents (most of whom were Utah Policy Daily readers) support some sort of expansion of mass transit options for Utah communities; 76.7% support the partnering of local and state governments to fund critical state transportation projects; and 54.6% support partnering with private companies to help facilitate funding shortfalls. You can read the full survey results summary here.

Charter School Report

The Utah Foundation has released an evaluation of the challenges facing Utah charter schools. The top finding: "Utah charter schools face significant financial challenges, chiefly a gap in funding that leaves charter schools with about $800 less per pupil than other Utah public schools." The gap is the result of three factors: Differences in student populations; ineligibility for funds; and funding formula shortfalls.

Charter schools face funding risks because of their dependence on federal grants that are competitively offered to every state. Utah must stay in competitive or face millions of dollars in costs to compensate for lost funds. In addition, charter schools face difficulties in financing school facilities, providing adequate salaries and benefits for teachers, and covering administrative costs. The full report can be read here

Podcast Watch

The lineup on Jennifer Napier-Pearce’s InsideUtah.com for Friday includes Real Salt Lake choosing Sandy over Rocky soil for its new stadium…Salt Lake County Peter Corroon’s (:56) thoughts, plus analysis from citizen watchdog Claire Geddes and Salt Lake Chamber CEO/President Lane Beattie (5:00). Also, BYU professor Gary Cornia (11:07) – part of the brains behind Governor Jon Huntsman’s flatter tax – on why 5 percent just makes sense; Kennecott Land V.P. Vicki Varela (16:20) on the company’s massive vision to develop Salt Lake’s West Bench; and KRCL’s Babs Delay (22:28) on the role of women in policymaking.

Reader Response

Hello From China

Dear Utah Policy: . . . “I appreciate your sending me your briefing.  Currently, my husband and I are in China and will be for the next 5 months.  We appreciate the update on current issues in Utah.  Thank you for keeping us informed.”  – Maryann Andrus

UPD Helps Out KSL

“Thanks for your help (finding an evening talk show host). I've received more than 50 submissions of nominations from your readers.  The response has been terrific.  There are several individuals I plan to talk with.  Thanks for your help with this search for a quality talent to help KSL in our effort to further strengthen our already firm local news and talk image.  With this talk show addition, we will be local at least 14 hours every day.” – Russ Hill, KSL Radio news and program director.

Link to Channel 17

Gentlemen: “What a great service you provide through Utahpolicy.com!  I can only thank you for the diligent effort you put into keeping the public informed. It is my hope that you will consider adding our web site to your link listings under “Local Television,” especially since we are now webcasting 24/7.  It is an exciting time for Davis Cable 17 and we look forward to a long and mutually productive relationship with you.”  – J. Scott Iverson (Note: Channel 17 is now listed with other TV stations at www.utahpolicy.com.)

National Politics

Finally, spending cut fever is hitting Washington (National Journal). . . . The Republican National Committee holds its first-ever conference call for conservative bloggers to try tone down the outcry over the nomination of Harriet Miers (National Journal Blogroll).

Casual Friday

At the Utah Senate Blog, Sen. Lyle Hillyard waxes philosophical about gardening: "So much of my work as an attorney and legislator leaves me feeling like I have not accomplished anything -- but one hour in the garden quickly shows the impact of my efforts. There is also something about working in the quiet time of early morning or just as it is getting dark. There is nothing like 'new potatoes', fresh corn on the cob, tomatoes, or raspberries all freshly picked and eaten."

A Fisherman is Old . . .

An essay by the late LaVarr B. Webb

A fisherman is old… When his first fishing partner, his Dad, has been dead for 20 years or more. . . . When his old fishing partners, his sons, have sons of their own to fish with, and . . . When his sons are, generally, too busy with their careers to go fishing.

A fisherman is old… When his mind is a golden book of memories that can be read to old fishing buddies and grandchildren alike.

Like the first fishing trip after he was married in 1940, when he hooked a very large brown trout, four pounds or more, and after fighting it for several minutes, tried to lift it up out of the stream, but it was heavy, and its nose kept catching on the lip of the stream bank.  He, afraid of losing it, called to his beautiful new wife, “Reach down and grab the fish,” but all she did was dance up and down, saying excitedly over and over, “You got a big one; you got a big one!”  Finally, he, knowing that he had a big one, tried to gently ease it up and over the bank, but his line broke, and he watched helplessly as the fish, carrying his only Mormon Girl fly and his new tapered leader, flopped back into the stream.

Like the time he took a troop of Scouts up to Chalk Creek, and told them that he would tend camp, prepare meals and wash dishes while they fished.  After fishing for several hours, the Scouts came back to camp, and complained, “There’s no fish in this creek.”  So he said, “I’ll make a deal with you; I’ll go fishing, and if I catch my limit, you guys will have to tend camp, cook the meals, and wash the dishes.”

The kids “Haw, hawed.” “You can’t catch any fish because we used up all the worms.”  He left them jeering, and as he walked up the stream, captured several fat, lively grasshoppers.  Within two hours he caught his limit. As he approached the camp, the Scouts again began to jeer, “Didn’t catch any, did you? There’s no fish in the creek, are there?”

As he laid those fat rainbows out before them, their jeers turned to, “How did you catch them?  What did you use for bait?”

He said, “Grasshoppers.”  Within seconds, there were Scouts all over the hillsides catching grasshoppers as he, happily, went back to his camp chores.

Like the time he was teaching a young grandson how to fish.  The boy caught one, and cried, “Grandpa, what do I do now,” and he said, “Pull it out.”  So the boy gave a hefty heave, and the trout cleared the water and sailed toward his head.  He dropped the pole, and ran, and as the fish flopped on the ground, Grandpa called, “Come back; where are you going?” Hesitantly he came back to his side, and asked, “Does it bite?”

Like the time the whole family managed to get together on a fishing trip. On the stream, he, lagging behind, giving his grandsons, sons, and sons-in-law first chance at the stream and its holes, ties into a fat, four-pound cutthroat trout, battles with its twisting, rolling, and leaping power in the swiftly moving stream, and brings it to the bank in front of his oldest son.  As his son reaches down to pick up the fish, he hears him say, “Dad, I don’t know how you do it.  At least 10 people fished that hole in the last hour, and didn’t get a thing.”

A fisherman is old… When, on a fishing trip with part of his family, he sees one of his grandsons wearing a Walkman, the headphones of that high fidelity miniature tape player clamped tight to his head, and he realizes, sadly, that his grandson’s world is not made up of camping trips, fish stories, the big one waiting in the next hole, or the singing of the wind in the pine trees, but rather, this boy’s world revolves around the all-pervading beat of hard rock bands and the “music” his grandfather cannot comprehend, let alone enjoy.

A fisherman is old…When on another fishing trip, he hears the exultant cry, “I got a big one, I got a big one,” and he looks up to see another grandson, perched on a large rock, high above the birch and wild rose lined banks of a deep hole, trying the lift a thrashing, two to three pound cutthroat up to where he is standing.  Then he watches, unable to help, as the fish, with a desperate flip, throws the hook, dives back into the water, and he hears the anguished cry of the grandson, “Oh, no, I lost him.”  Then he smiles as he remembers that his son, the boy’s father, perched on that same rock, lost a similar fish about 20 years before.

A fisherman is old…When the clock radio in his RV sounds off, and his wife looks at its brilliant digital numbers, and says, “It’s only six o’clock.  You  had better stay in bed at least another hour.” And he does. … When he hears the furnace go on, and watches his wife fix breakfast in her fancy RV kitchen, and he remembers with nostalgia the cold back and warm belly and the sooty black pans on an open campfire, … and, when he chuckles as he remembers standing as close as possible to that open fire, and then kneeling down and feeling the branding heat of the rivets on the fly of his old Levis.

A fisherman is old… When he reads that the purists, the artificial bait only clique, advocate that, “The true sportsman will return all fish into the stream or lake in which they were caught, so that other fishermen can have the experience of catching them,” and then he remembers when, during the Great Depression, fishing licenses cost more than a day’s wages, and fishing wasn’t just a sport, but a means of putting meat on the table, thereby helping to defray, not only the cost of the license, but the cost of the trip as well. … When he goes to buy a favorite reel, and is told that it will cost him $65.00, and he says, “Hell, I can remember when that little old thing only cost $2.98,” … and the clerk looks him right in the eye and says, “Mr. Webb, you have lived too long.”

A fisherman is old…When after 50 or more years, he drives by the productive, free flowing Mill Creek of his youth, and finds the old fishing holes dredged, the native wild shrubs, weeds, and grass on the banks grubbed out and replaced with sculptured lawns, neat concrete paths, and condos, hundreds of look-alike, two story, wood-brick condos, and the stream, itself, sterile, and spanned every few hundred feet by “perfect” little redwood bridges.

Or when…He returns to a stream that he, as a boy of ten, fished with his father.  There he finds, not the willows, the birch, the wild rose, and the massive Ponderosa Pines that had lined the banks and patched the green meadows but, rather, he finds the meadows over grazed and dusty, the Ponderosa nothing but stumps, the stream banks barren, eroded slopes, and what had been a graveled, beaver dammed stream bed, mud bottomed, churned by countless herds of cattle, and scoured by unrestrained and relentless floods.

A fisherman is old…When he probably knows more about a much-loved stream and its fish than anyone else alive, and while his fishing companions complain about no strikes on flies and no bites on worms, he catches a few of the grasshoppers that he kicks up as he walks to his favorite holes.  Then he brings back to camp, an hour or so later, a four-pound brown and several lesser fish, and he hears one of his old fishing buddies mutter, “That guy could catch fish in a bathtub.”

A fisherman is old…When he walks every morning for the sole purpose of staying in shape, so that he can wade his favorite stream without giving out. …When he finds it almost impossible to duck under brush and climb over logs,   … and, When he finally finds stable footing on a rock, looks down at the fast flowing stream, and suddenly finds himself face down in the water.

A fisherman is old…When he measures time by the number of pills left in his pill bottle. Thirty days, 99 pills, and the bottle is empty.  Yet, those pills are what make it possible for him to go fishing.

A fisherman is old…When he watches light, first a haze, gauze like, making a silhouette of the eastern hills, then a curtain that blots out the stars and leaves the brilliance of Venus, the red wrath of Mars, and the pin prick of Jupiter poking holes in the glowing velvet of the sky, . . .and he listens to the rustling scurry and the chattering call of a pine squirrel as it begins a new day, and notes the last crescendo of the Western Chat’s all night song, … and, because of a long stubborn struggle with heart attacks, or cancer, or leukemia, looks up and says, “Thanks, it has been a pleasure, especially because this, perhaps, is the last time,” … then he sees a young grandson crawl out of a pup tent that the boy, by himself, had pitched, and smiles as a surge of love and continuity flows through him, … and hears the grandson ask, “Is it time to go fishing, Grandpa?”

“Yes,” he answers, “Yes, it certainly is.”



 

Friday
October 14, 2005



National Headlines

Potential '08 presidential candidate Mitt Romney gained unique perspective on dealing with terrorism threat from experience running Salt Lake Winter Olympics, which took place in the fearful months just after 9/11 (Weekly Standard).

Kane County being sued by environmental groups for "for enacting an ordinance that would illegally allow destructive off-road vehicle (ORV) use on protected public lands" (Earthjustice).

Idaho Gov. Dirk Kempthorne considering joining his Utah and New Mexico counterparts in attempting to establish a Western presidential primary (KPVI).

Local Headlines

Logan Herald Journal

- Cache ‘needs' water voice, says Sen. Lyle Hillyard

Davis County Clipper

- Not so fast on Legacy, say accord opponents

- Centerville candidates: a choice between youth or wisdom

- W. Bountiful canvases vote, approves new auditing firm

- Bennett emphasizes need to fund defense, Hill AFB

Deseret Morning News

- Calling Utah home: Churches choose to stay out of questions of status of illegal immigrants

- Citizenship status questions ignored; counting cost comes 2nd

- Will RSL stadium sell beer?

- City attorney OK'd Rocky's Torino, Italy trip

- Planning for 2 stations for TRAX near hub OK'd

- Lee Benson: Old friends once played fowl games at RSL stadium site

- Provo mayoral candidates Billings, Bailey pick up where they left off in '01

- Governor's office to hold summit on roads and transit issues

- Sunday ban went unnoticed by South S.L., but it's ended

- Environmentalists' lawsuit says Kane County reopened trails on public lands

- Shurtleff proposes new tack on hate-crime law

- Eagle Mountain folk are happy, poll shows

- Huntsman makes new staff appointments in wake of chief of staff's resignation

- Bob Bernick Jr.: Romney doesn't own presidential nomination

- Editorial: Soccer stadium economics: How much public money will be involved, and in what form?

- Editorial: We applaud Mary Kaye Huntsma's campaign to call off the name calling

St. George Spectrum

- Editorial: Immigration office belongs in St. George

Salt Lake Tribune

- Rolly: Utah may not speak Latinos' language but marketing companies do

- City attorney says he OK'd Rocky's Torin, Italy tab

- SLC doesn't want to pay for Sandy stadium

- Roy recount fails to alter election result

- Environmental activists suing Kane County over roads access on public lands

- South S.L. suspends Sunday beer ban

- Mayoral debate heats up over Provo reserves, public safety

- Funding crisis could force National Parks to go more commercial

- Editorial: Gay-Straight Club: Provo School District has chance to show new tolerance

- Investigation by Legislature shows criminals are working in day care industry


Message Center

Winning at the Legislature

Sponsored Essay by LaVarr Webb

I don’t know how many times I’ve heard someone lament, at the end of an unsuccessful legislative session, “If only we’d had more time to communicate our position! Legislators just didn’t understand the importance of our issue and what we were trying to do.”

Most legislative failures are failures of communications. But the time to communicate, the time to educate, isn’t after a session starts. In fact, by then it’s probably too late. During a brief, intense 45-day session, Utah’s 104 lawmakers are incredibly busy, with hundreds of issues hitting them all at once. They are inundated with letters, e-mail messages, position papers and phone calls. They run from meeting to meeting, early in the morning to late in the evening. And it only gets worse as the session goes on.

If they don’t go into the session already having some knowledge about an issue, if they aren’t already aware of the significance and rationale of a position, then it may be too late to generate enough support to pass or defeat a proposal.

The time to communicate with lawmakers, the executive branch and other policymakers and opinion leaders is well in advance of a legislative session. That’s the time to educate.

And right now is the time to start. We are only about 12 weeks away from the next session, with the holiday season taking a chunk of that time. A lot of legislation is already being drafted. Work is being done on the budget. Interim committees and task forces are finishing up their work. Lawmakers are planning their priorities and goals for the upcoming session. Now is the time to communicate with them, before it’s too late.

Utah Policy Daily provides an excellent channel to deliver persuasive messages to legislators and other policymakers and opinion leaders. UPD is being read on a daily basis by most lawmakers, along with more than 8,000 other politically-active citizens.

By publishing advocacy essays, sponsored articles or advertorials in UPD, you can reach, and educate, lawmakers and others who are critical to your success. A series of articles over the next several weeks could provide enormous visibility and understanding of your issue or proposal.

UPD’s space is somewhat limited and we expect a lot of interest in this advocacy advertising channel. So reserve your space now. Discuss the possibilities with Business Development Director Mark Towner, 801.502.9134, mark@utahpolicy.com.


Political Calendar

KCPW Radio Logo

KCPW Radio 1010AM · 88.3FM · 105.3FM

Please submit calendar items to Daily@UtahPolicy.com

- Oct 14: Gov. Jon Huntsman, Jr. and Lt. Gov. Gary Herbert's Transportation Summit 2005, Davis Conference Center, 800 W Heritage Park Blvd, Layton. A continental breakfast will begin at 8:30 am, the program will begin at 9am sharp, ending around 3pm with a served lunch at 11:30am.  To RSVP or for more information contact Tyler Allen at 801-538-1041 or email tylerallen@utah.gov.
- Oct 14: Tax Review Commission, 9 am, room W125.
- Oct 14: KCPW's Midday Metro " Another Presidential Visit," 10:10 am. Dr. Cynthia Bioteau, president of Salt Lake Community College, talks about her vision for Utah's community college, including a new four-year bio-tech program.
- Oct 14: KCPW's Midday Metro "Newsweek and the Mormons," 10:40 am.  Author Elise Soukup talks about this week's Newsweek cover story on the LDS Church.
- Oct 14: Hinckley Forum "The Arab League and the Middle East Situation," 10:45 am.  Forum will feature His Excellency Hussein Hassouna.
- Oct 15: Dr. Kathy Escamilla will be doing a 3 hour seminar titled, "Use A Child's First Language to Close the Achievement Gap,"  9 am to 12 pm at Mi Ranchito Grill at 9550 S State.  Contact Barbara Lovejoy at bclovejoy@msn.com for more information.
- Oct 15: Former Arizona Governor and Secretary of the Interior under the Clinton Administration Bruce Babbitt public lecture, 11 am, Westminster College, Vieve Gore Concert Hall. Babbitt will discuss his newly published book “Cities in the Wilderness: A New Vision of Land Use in America.” The book explores the importance of having a national vision of land use. The lecture is free and open to the public.
- Oct 16: Utah Citizens Alliance Meeting, 7 pm, Law & Justice Center, 645 S 200 E, Salt Lake City. Dr. Anne Blake-Tracy will be guest speaker on the pharmaceutical companies. How are drug companies misguiding the public?
- Oct 17: Special Districts Subcommittee of the Political Subdivisions Interim Committee, 9 am, room W110.
- Oct 17: Senate Judicial Confirmation Committee, 10 am, room W140.
- Oct 17:  Democrats of Southern Utah Monthly Meeting,11:30 am, Dixie Center, 1835 Convention Center Drive.  The speaker will be Pete Ashdown, candidate U.S. Senate and the topic "A Better Approach in Government."
- Oct 17: Tourism Task Force, 1 pm, room W110.
- Oct 17: Legislative Process Committee, 2 pm, room W130.
- Oct 17: Washington County Democrats Executive Council/Town Hall, 6:15 pm, Santa Clara Library, 1099 N Lava Flow Drive.  All are invited.
- Oct 18: Executive Offices and Criminal Justice Appropriations Subcommittee, 9 am, West Jordan Courthouse, 8080 S Redwood Rd, West Jordan.
- Oct 18: Davis Area Convention and Visitors Bureau Legislative event at Antelope Island, 12 to 4:30 pm.  For more information email Lois Bowden at lois@davisareacvb.com or call 801-774-8200.
- Oct 18: Executive Appropriations Committee, 1 pm, room W135.
- Oct 18: Government Records Access and Management Task Force, 1:30 pm, room W125.
- Oct 18: Education Excellence Utah presents Parental Choice and Public Education, 7:30 to 11:30 am, Hilton Salt Lake City Center, 255 S West Temple. The keynote speaker will be John Fund of the Wall Street Journal. Conference will discuss the impact of parental choice on public education and society. Please RSVP by Oct 14th to Jessica at 801-532-1448 or jhoff@xmission.com.

- Oct 19: Legislative Interim Committee Day.
- Oct 19: Legislative meetings scheduled throughout day.  See Legislative calendar for details.
- Oct 19: Salt Lake City Tax Reform Task Force Public Hearing, 5:30 p.m, Utah State Capitol, West Building. The Task Force is holding public hearings in October and encourages all Utahns to attend, ask questions, and give thoughtful feedback on the various proposals. Phil Dean and Bryant Howe, of Legislative Research and General Counsel, are also available to answer questions at 801-538-1032.
- Oct 19: Voice for Moderation meeting, 6:30 to 8 pm, Anderson/Foothill Library.  There will be a professional panel that will discuss the causes of  escalating  health insurance costs and the impact of the uninsured or under-insured on these costs. The meeting is open to everyone.
- Oct 20: Occupational and Professional Licensure Review Committee, 9 am, room W135.
- Oct 20: Water Issues Task Force, 9 am, room W125.
- Oct 20: Brigham Young University Kennedy Center will host the Chinese ambassador to the United States H.E. Zhou Wenzhong, 11 am, room 250 SWKT.

- Oct 20: Child Welfare Legislative Oversight Panel, 3 pm, room W020.
- Oct 20:  Utah Republican Women's PAC "Utah Winning Women Inaugural Gala," 6:30 pm to 8:30 pm, Wells Fargo Building, 23rd Floor, 299 South Main Street, Salt Lake City.  For more information contact Paige Marriott at 202-549-2558 or paige@marriottgroup.com or Karen Hammond at 801-201-0859 or karen.hammond@juno.com.

- Oct 21: Hinckley Forum "Chinese Ambassador His Excellency Zhou Wenzhong, Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of the People's Republic of China to the United States, 10:45 to 11:45 am.
- Oct 21: Summitt County Democrats meeting, 7 pm, Rob and Alison Weyher’s house, 8744 Redden Road (Silver Creek), Park City. For information contact Rob’s office 435-649-9240.
- Oct 23: Green Party of Utah Monthly Council meeting, 10 am, Salt Lake County Government Complex, 2100 South State Street.
- Oct 25: Hinckley Forum "South Africa in Transition," 9:10 am.  Talk will be by Patrick Hayford, Director, Department of Political Affairs & former Director of African Affairs in the Secretary-General's Office of the United Nations.

- See the entire calendar


Elected Officials Birthday List


Utah Policy Daily is a service
of Utah Policy.com

Publisher: LaVarr Webb
Editor: Paul Hollingshead
News: Golden Webb
Calendar and Subscriptions: Luci W. Hollingshead

Business Development: Mark Towner