Today's political briefing: Key developments
and analysis for Utah policymakers

Utah Policy Daily is a free newsletter published
business days by Utah Policy.com. Send us your
comments and ideas
. See our Policy Daily Archive.
Please forward this to friends.

Subscribe or Unsubscribe


Message Center

(Links to Advertisements, Advertorials, Sponsored Articles, and Client Advocacy Essays.)

Why USTAR Needs Buildings

New research facilities are central to the USTAR Economic Development Initiative being proposed by Utah’s business community. Read more below.


News Highlights

Squabbling over billboards threatens Legacy Parkway negotiations (Deseret Morning News) as Salt Lake Chamber endorses agreement (Morning News); meanwhile, columnist Paul Rolly reports that Union Pacific west side rail line is now part of the discussion (Salt Lake Tribune).

S.L. Mayor Rocky Anderson seeking donors for London trip (Tribune).

UEA teachers to lobby grassroots to put pressure on Legislature for more money (Tribune). Parting with tradition, UEA convention leaves Gov. Jon Huntsman out of lineup (Deseret Morning News).


Quote of the Day

Investment in the future is a great thing. And who wouldn't want every high schooler to have a laptop, CD books, access to an electronic world of knowledge? USTAR sounds amazing — $5 billion in new tax revenues over 35 years, 123,000 new high-paying jobs, $62 billion in personal income growth. In the 2006 Legislature we'll see how all the wishes come out against all the politics.”

-- Political columnist Bob Bernick juxtaposing legislative wish lists with possible tax cut sentiments (Morning News).



Friday Buzz
Written by LaVarr Webb & Associates

Time for Cautious Budgeting?

Even though tax revenues remain strong, the governor and Legislature are likely to take a careful approach in budgeting and cutting taxes in the upcoming legislative session. With inflationary pressures, sky-high energy costs, a burgeoning federal deficit, high personal debt, a costly war in Iraq, and multi-billion dollar restoration efforts in the Gulf Coast, the national economy is considered somewhat fragile even though so far it remains solid.

In recent conversations, both Senate President John Valentine and Huntsman Chief of Staff Neil Ashdown said revenues in Utah are coming in strong, but small signs of potential softness are appearing. Neither believe now is the time for big tax cuts, although a relatively small cut (in the $20 to $30 million range) in income taxes is possible as a result of tax reform.

In a time of uncertainty, it makes sense to budget carefully. That means using most of the surplus for infrastructure like buildings and transportation instead of absorbing it into base operating budgets. That way, if the economy turns down, those capital areas can be cut back without having to slash programs and state employee jobs. Prudent budgeting also means avoiding a big tax cut that could be hurtful if the economy slows.

Hamlet Teams with UTOPIA

Hamlet Homes is partnering with UTOPIA to provide ultra-broadband connections in a new town home development in Murray. See Utah Business article.

Podcast Watch

Check out Jennifer Napier-Pearce’s InsideUtah.com, which this week features a conversation with Gov. Jon Huntsman on taxes, the Legislature and reflections on the past 10 months (:50); plus, a progress report on the Guv from watchdog Claire Geddes and State Sen. Greg Bell (8:30). Also, University of Utah political science professor Matt Burbank on why Utahns love President Bush (15:14); Connect Magazine on a red flag for Utah entrepreneurs (19:16); and Sunstone Magazine on technology and faith (23:09).

Blog Watch

At the New West Network blog, Ken Bingham has a unique take on the liberal/conservative divide in Utah, one that perhaps defies conventional wisdom. Says Bingham:

"There is no place in the country, politically or socially, like the State of Utah. It is unique in the sense that no other place holds a dichotomy of faith and secularism that often are at odds with one another. In most areas of the country, politics is merely an argument with Republicans and Democrats, liberals and conservatives but, in Utah, religion is added to the mix -- that changes the dynamic considerably.

"We consider Utah to be a conservative state. However, Salt Lake City elected and re-elected one of the most liberal mayors in the nation. Salt Lake has become a liberal city and it is precisely because of the divide between LDS conservatives and non-LDS liberals.

"There are those who have said that before moving to Utah they considered themselves conservative, but when they came to Utah they became liberals. Many who lean toward liberalism will come to Salt Lake and, because of the perceived conservative climate of the state, will become super-liberals -- as if their ideology was put through a magnifying glass. For example, other states also have strict liquor laws (some have more restrictions than Utah). Those who may not have been concerned over the laws in other states will come here and resent ours because they feel it is 'Mormon-imposed.'

"On the other side of the coin, the LDS population doesn't want to be seen as flexing their political muscle too much as to not offend those of other faiths (or no faith at all). There are many LDS who would consider themselves conservatives but, to avoid appearing overbearing or too 'Molly Mormon,' will either bow out of the political process or vote for less conservative candidates in order to accommodate the non-LDS population. This is especially prevalent in Salt Lake City, where pollster Dan Jones reported that if more LDS--especially women--voted in the last mayoral election, Rocky Anderson would not have been re-elected.

”Utah is a Republican state but ironically, because of this dichotomy, it is becoming more and more liberal. Not that liberals are a majority, but because conservatives have been intimidated or lulled into silence."

Washington Watch

Sex Offender Bill Clears Committee

Sen. Orrin Hatch’s Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act cleared the Senate Judiciary Committee Thursday.  The legislation, which would overhaul the nation’s sex offender laws, was also championed by Ed Smart, father of Elizabeth Smart.  “For too long, too many sex offenders have been treated like petty criminals,” Hatch said. “These pedophiles prey on our children and will continue to do so unless stopped.”

House Protects Gun Makers

On Thursday the House passed S. 397, which would protect gun manufacturers from frivolous lawsuits. Reps. Chris Cannon, Jim Matheson, and Rob Bishop all voted yea. Sen. Orrin Hatch sponsored the legislation, which is virtually identical to H.R. 800, a bill co-sponsored by Cannon and which he helped move through the House Judiciary Committee. “This bill cracks down on junk lawsuits that are overwhelming law-abiding small businesses that are central to our military and those who wish to exercise their Second Amendment rights,” Hatch said. 

Casual Friday

Burr Trail: The Most Beautiful Back Road of Them All

By Golden Webb

            I’d awakened that morning in Salt Lake to winter smog. Not a cool, wet fog on little cat feet, but one of the Wasatch Front’s black-smoggy-death-clouds, the kind that kills stray dogs. No matter. Smog like that gives me an excuse to flee to the Elysian graces of the desert, where the air smells like sagebrush instead of car exhaust, where the only particulates in the air are empty locust husks and fine clean granules of blowsand.

            I headed south on I-15 in my Chevy truck, traveling at first without a destination in mind, only a direction. I was hungry for beauty but only had a day to find it. I needed a superlative road to explore -- one of Utah’s beautiful backways. Almost unconsciously I found myself drifting southeast across the state, following some kind of inner homing impulse like a wistful pigeon, toward the Burr Trail -- the most beautiful back road of them all. An officially designated “National Scenic Backway,” the Burr Trail is a partially paved route that connects Highway 12 in the town of Boulder with Bullfrog Marina on Lake Powell. Beginning in the foothills of the Aquarius Plateau, it winds down through the spectacular backcountry areas of Grand Staircase-Escalante NM, Capitol Reef NP, and Glen Canyon NRA, passing through a remarkable quilted patchwork of federally protected lands and proposed wilderness areas.

            Cloistered for decades by its remoteness and rugged topography, until recently the Burr Trail was a hard place to explore, one of those rare 70+-mile roads in the Lower 48 where a high-clearance (and, in some cases, four-wheel drive) vehicle was essential to see much of its length. That changed in the 90s, when all but the 16 miles of road within Capitol Reef was paved by the BLM. Aside from a few environmentalists (whose delicate esthetic preferences were bruised), most people have welcomed this increased accessibility. The Burr Trail now offers something for both the casual automobile sightseer and the hardcore explorer. The road takes the car-bound into some of Utah's most beautiful and extraordinary country, offering glorious views from every direction; it also offers canyoneers and hikers backcountry access to the wild-and-woolly Eastern Escalante Drainage, one of the world’s most spectacular canyon systems, and to the Waterpocket Fold, with its little-explored slots and high slickrock ramparts.

            Sadly, I don’t have time on this trip to get out and roam on my feet; I plan on seeing what I can from my truck. I drive eastward out of Boulder on shiny new chip-sealed asphalt, past bucolic green fields and white checkerboard Navajo Sandstone domes. Stately ponderosa pines tower over dry sandy washes. Off to the northwest the snow-bound bulk of the Aquarius Plateau pushes into the clear January sky.

            The road wraps around a cliff and swings south, plunging down to the dancing waters of The Gulch. One of Grand Staircase-Escalante’s most popular canyons due to its easy walking and glorious scenery, in the winter The Gulch exhibits a spare sylvan beauty: leafless cottonwood groves rise above silvery sage and a muddy stream. The place seems completely abandoned. Not a single solitary soul in sight -- no cars at the trailhead, no other cars on the road, not even an airplane in the sky. The empty road means only one thing: emptier backcountry. Oh the humanity! Equipped with more time, I could have had The Gulch all to my greedy little misanthropic self -- surely a rare opportunity.

            Instead, and with deep regret, I drive right on by. I cross over a concrete bridge and enter the Stygian corridor of Long Canyon. Soaring Wingate cliff faces cast long cold shadows across the road even though it’s midday. The canyon floor on either side of the road is buried in rolling slopes of fallen riprap and scree. Pinyon pines, twisted junipers, and tall ponderosas grow in unlikely places out of the rocky detritus; massive sandstone blocks and boulders stand balanced at the angle of repose, waiting patiently for an earthquake. The only regularity in the scene is the mostly-straight road, which I follow until it tops out in the heights of the Circle Cliffs Upwarp.

            The canyon walls fall away and the horizon leaps back several miles. I pull over at a scenic overlook, hop out of the truck. The sky above my head is 360 degrees of blue; at approximately 6,600 feet in elevation, the air has a good clean bite to it. The overlook breaks on an expansive view of the Circle Cliffs: inward-facing Wingate ramparts that encircle a huge basin of pinyon-juniper woodlands and rust-colored badland slopes. Patterns in the landscape carry the eye past castellated cliffs to distant white peaks on the eastern skyline -- the Henry Mountains, the last-surveyed and last-named mountain range in the continental United States.

            Wild country. I can’t wait to get down into it.

            I turn to get back in my truck. A huge jackrabbit spooks from a scatter of junipers in an explosion of movement and sound. I recoil in terror. The jackrabbit bounds in a panicked zigzag back into the orange mouth of Long Canyon: a blur of white and a puff of dust, then stillness. Everything is as it was before -- except my pride. “Mangy rabbit,” I say as I climb into the cab. Actually, not a rabbit at all but a hare -- or, in Edward Abbey’s more precise terminology, a “black-tailed mule-eared wall-eyed lagomorph.” I make a silent promise to come back here with a .22 and go rabbit hunting.

            I drop into the Circle Cliffs amphitheater and race across its vast basin. A bug glances off the windshield, leaving a pastel smear on the glass at eye level. I can’t understand how a bug could be flying around down here in January, but there it is. I pass through the Studhorse Peaks (named after the stallions that stood vigil on the high ground here, guarding their mares) and descend to the entrance of Capitol Reef National Park. Here the pavement ends abruptly, the velvety smooth macadam giving way to slick gumbo mud.

            My truck slews in the deep moist ruts; sticky wet clay thumps in the wheel wells. This is the Burr Trail as it was 30 years ago -- well nigh impassable. I shift into 4WD High and slalom along for a few miles toward a break in the slickrock mass of the Waterpocket Fold. I splash through a half-foot of flowing water where the road follows the course of a (usually dry) streambed, pass through the seam in the cliffs, and pull off the road at the top of the infamous Burr Canyon switchbacks. A century and a half ago these switchbacks were the crux of the cattle trail built by John Atlantic Burr, a rancher who moved his herds back and forth between the Aquarius Plateau and Bullfrog Basin on the Colorado River. According to guidebook author Steve Allen, “Burr died alone on the desert while trying to remedy a urinary tract blockage with a piece of wire.”

            If Burr’s ghost lurks in this country, I’m sure it often stops at this high desert perch to admire the beauty. The air up here is thick with the distilled magical essence of the Burr Trail: if I could bottle it up somehow and sell it to the Japanese, I’d be richer than a Rockefeller. To the east, honey-colored cliffs frame a phantasmagoric panorama of eroded mesas and snowy mountains. To my right and left the Fold’s knobby ridgeline extends into the wings, the devil’s very own backbone pointing south toward Lake Powell and north toward Thousand Lake Mountain. Below my feet the road drops in a series of vertiginous Z’s to the cool shadows of Burr Canyon.

            It’s too much to take in all at once. I mentally slice the scene up into frames and savor each one individually: The Fold’s Navajo sandstone glowing in the rich afternoon sunlight; the bruise-gray badland hills spilling off the crumbling rim of Swap Mesa; the laccolithic cones of Mount Pennell and Mount Hillers floating above the desert flats, their shimmering, snow-clad slopes white as sun-bleached bone.

            Gorgeous, stunning, wild country. I can’t wait to get down into it.

            As I climb back in the truck, a snippet of verse pops into my head: “I like a road that leads away to prospects bright and fair, a road that is an ordered road, like a nun’s evening prayer; but best of all I love a road that leads to God knows where.” Another poet, Shakespeare, said, “All roads lead to Rome.” In Utah’s desert country, all backroads lead to adventure and discovery. I shift into 4WD Low, point my Chevy down the switchbacks, and continue my journey on the most beautiful backroad of them all, sinking deeper into its matrix of geology, history, and raw beauty.



 

Friday
October 21 2005



Local Headlines

Salt Lake Tribune

- Rolly: New closed-door deal could yet sidetrack the Legacy agreement

- High mercury levels in Utah under scrutiny

- Mercury: Q and A

- Educators take plight to the voters

- SLC seeks stricter open space designation

- Kennedy hate crimes rider may doom Hatch's sex offender bill

- Sandy planners rule proposal signs at gravel pit can stay

- Huntsman names deputy schools superintendent to key position

- Farmington mayoral candidates discuss growth

- The latest census finds the daily commuter onslaught nearly doubles the population-for better or worse

- Rep. Harper submits a 'compromise' child welfare reform bill

- Who should pick up tab for Rocky's London trip?

- Rocky's backers, critics invited to speak up

- Editorial: CHANGES TO GRAMA: Keep the light on

Standard-Examiner

- Huntsman gives pep talk to WSU students

- Coalition of Religious Communities hosts state tax proposal discussion in Ogden

St. George Spectrum

- Santa Clara candidates answer questions at luncheon

Deseret Morning News

- Salt Lake ranks No. 3 in commuter use

- UEA skips traditional pep talk by Huntsman

- Billings rakes in cash

- More delay for Legacy?

- Rocky promotes health benefits for gays at national summit

- Chamber pushes Legacy talks

- Provo mayoral, council candidates to debate on TV

- Bob Bernick Jr.: Let's hope USTAR outshines cold fusion

- Editorial: Repeal criminal libel law


Advocacy Essay

Leading-Edge Research Requires Excellent Laboratory Facilities

(One in a series of articles about the USTAR Economic Development Initiative, which will be addressed in the 2006 Legislature.)

One of the key questions asked of the Utah Science, Technology and Research (USTAR) initiative is why so much money needs to be spent on buildings and laboratory equipment.

The answer is very simple:  To attract world-class research teams of up to 50 members each, quality laboratory space and equipment is required. The stars of scientific research who can develop products that can be commercialized, creating businesses and whole new industries, expect top-notch facilities in which to conduct their research.

Without good infrastructure, these leading-edge research teams will not be interested in re-locating to Utah. 

There are many current examples of how other states and university systems are putting enormous amounts of money into research facilities to attract world-class scientists. The Chicago Tribune, for example, published a story this week about the University of Chicago breaking ground on a new $162.5 million, 330,760-square-foot Center of Biomedical Discovery “that it hopes will attract top-notch researchers in cancer and children’s health.”

The facility will house hundreds of scientists working to understand such medical issues as how cancer spreads and why blood vessels can leak. Half of the building will be devoted to the Institute for Molecular Pediatric Science, which is aggressively recruiting faculty and researchers who can help understand children's diseases.

At Arizona State University, several new building devoted to research and costing hundreds of millions of dollars are being constructed, adding more than 1 million square feet of world-class laboratory and office space as ASU attempts to “transform itself into a highly competitive research institution,” according to ASU’s alumni publication. The facilities will be used to attract top-level research teams to ASU.

Part of Utah’s USTAR proposal requests $170 million for laboratory equipment and two new research buildings, one at the University of Utah and the other at Utah State. Direct appropriations, state bonding and possibly private financing could be used to raise money for the buildings. An oversight panel consisting of representatives from the Legislature, the Governor’s Office and business would control expenditures and see that the buildings were used for the purposes intended and not for general university uses.

Without new facilities, Utah has little chance to compete with other research centers for world-class teams of scientists. Conservative projections by the Bureau of Economic and Business Research indicate that USTAR could be a big catalyst for economic development in Utah, generating far more new research grants, jobs, payroll, and tax dollars than the cost to the state.


Political Calendar

KCPW Radio Logo

Please submit calendar items to Daily@UtahPolicy.com

- Oct 21: Utah Education Association Convention, Salt Palace Convention Center, Salt Lake City.
- Oct 21: KCPW's Midday Metro, "Abierto, Cerrado," 10:10 am. The Utah Government Records and Management Act (GRAMA) is subject to change, so is the Open Meetings Act. Attorney General Mark Shurtleff and the Society of Professional Journalists will explain these issues, as well as the creation of a shield law for reporters. Email your questions to midday@kcpw.org.
- Oct 21: KCPW's Midday Metro, "Breyt Future," 10:40 am. South African writer, painter and activist Breyten Breytenbach talks to Midday Metro about art and the struggle for racial equality. He will speak and read from his works at the Main City Library this evening at 7:30.

- Oct 21: Hinckley Forum "Chinese Ambassador His Excellency Zhou Wenzhong, Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of the People's Republic of China to the United States, 10:45 to 11:45 am.
- Oct 21: Summitt County Democrats meeting, 7 pm, Rob and Alison Weyher’s house, 8744 Redden Road (Silver Creek), Park City. For information contact Rob’s office 435-649-9240.
- Oct 23: Green Party of Utah Monthly Council meeting, 10 am, Salt Lake County Government Complex, 2100 South State Street.
- Oct 25: Hinckley Forum "South Africa in Transition," 9:10 am.  Talk will be by Patrick Hayford, Director, Department of Political Affairs & former Director of African Affairs in the Secretary-General's Office of the United Nations.
- Oct 25: Vernal Tax Reform Task Force Public Hearing, 12 pm, Western Park, 300 E 200 S, Vernal. The Task Force is holding public hearings in October and encourages all Utahns to attend, ask questions, and give thoughtful feedback on the various proposals. Phil Dean and Bryant Howe, of Legislative Research and General Counsel, are also available to answer questions at 801-538-1032.
- Oct 25: Utah Poverty Partnership's "Meet the Salt Lake City Council Candidate Forum" for Salt Lake City District 7, 5 to 6 pm, Sprague City Library, 2131 S 1100 E. Any city resident is invited.
- Oct 25: House Speaker Greg Curtis "Tailgate Party," 6 pm. For more information call Kat Dayton at 801-580-4743.
- Oct 25: Price Tax Reform Task Force Public Hearing, 6 pm, County Commission Chambers, 120 E Main, Price. The Task Force is holding public hearings in October and encourages all Utahns to attend, ask questions, and give thoughtful feedback on the various proposals. Phil Dean and Bryant Howe, of Legislative Research and General Counsel, are also available to answer questions at 801-538-1032.
- Oct 25: U of U College Democrats meeting, 8 pm, OSH 255, the Hinckley Institute's Caucus Room, University of Utah campus.  For more information contact Breanne Miller at 702-324-8316 or breanne.miller@utah.edu.

- Oct 26: Hinckley Forum "Land Use Issues in the State of Utah," 9 am, Hinckley Caucus Room (OSH 255). Broadcasted live on KUER's Radiowest. Featuring Doug Fabrizio, Brian Hawthorne, Land Use Director, Blue Ribbon Coalition; Heidi McIntosh, Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance
- Oct 26: Provo Tax Reform Task Force Public Hearing, 6 pm, Dixon Middle School, 750 W 200 N, Provo. The Task Force is holding public hearings in October and encourages all Utahns to attend, ask questions, and give thoughtful feedback on the various proposals. Phil Dean and Bryant Howe, of Legislative Research and General Counsel, are also available to answer questions at 801-538-1032.
- Oct 26: Uintah County Libertarian Meeting, 8 pm, Golden Corral, 1096 West Highway 40, Vernal.
- Oct 27: Commerce and Revenue Appropriations Subcommittee, 8:30 am, Workforce Services Building, 751 E Quality Drive, American Fork.
- Oct 27: Cedar City Tax Reform Task Force Public Hearing, 12 pm, Cedar City Chambers (Old Post Office), 10 N Main, Cedar City. The Task Force is holding public hearings in October and encourages all Utahns to attend, ask questions, and give thoughtful feedback on the various proposals. Phil Dean and Bryant Howe, of Legislative Research and General Counsel, are also available to answer questions at 801-538-1032.
- Oct 27: St. George Tax Reform Task Force Public Hearing, 6 pm, Washington County Commission Chambers, 197 E Tabernacle Street, St. George. The Task Force is holding public hearings in October and encourages all Utahns to attend, ask questions, and give thoughtful feedback on the various proposals. Phil Dean and Bryant Howe, of Legislative Research and General Counsel, are also available to answer questions at 801-538-1032.
- Oct 27: Salt Lake County Libertarian Party Meeting, 7 pm, Rocky Mountain Pizza Company, 3977 Wasatch Boulevard, Salt Lake City.
- Oct 28: Coalition for Utah’s Future, sponsor of Envision Utah, 10th annual Common Good Awards Luncheon, 11:45 am, Little America Hotel, Salt Lake City.  The new chair of Envision Utah will be announced at the luncheon. Dr. Cecil O. Samuelson, President of Brigham Young University, will provide the keynote.  This year, the Coalition is proud to honor Stampin’ Up! and Volunteers of America, Utah for their significant community service.  Contact Kevin Fayles at (801) 303-1462 or kfayles@cuf-envision.org for more information
- Oct 28: "With a Little Help from My Friends," Utah Democratic Legislative Fundraiser and Tribute to the Arts featuring Broadway's Beatlemania accompanied by the Utah Symphony, with a pre-concert reception, 6:30 pm, Abravanel Hall.  Tickets: $200.  Limited seating.  Sponsorships available.  Contact Ben Lear at 801-209-1669 or learbjl@yahoo.com.
- Oct 29: Salt Lake County Democrats 1st Annual Halloween Party, 7 pm, Jewish Community Center, 2 N Medical Drive. DJ, socializing, dancing, munchies, a cash bar and a free drawing for a tub of Halloween items--scary and otherwise. Costumes (optional) with prizes for the best individual, couple, group and politician. $35 per person.
- Oct 31: Tourism Task Force, 10 am, room W110.
- Oct 2: Utah Poverty Partnership's "Meet the Salt Lake City Council Candidate Forum" for Salt Lake City District 3, 3:30 pm, Cathedral Pastoral Center # 27 "C" Street.  Any interested city resident is invited.
- Nov 2: West Valley City Meet the Candidates Night, General Election, 7 pm.
- Nov 2: Salt Lake City Democracy for America Meetup, 7 pm.

- See the entire calendar


Elected Officials Birthday List


Utah Policy Daily is a service
of Utah Policy.com

Publisher: LaVarr Webb
Editor: Paul Hollingshead
News: Golden Webb
Calendar and Subscriptions: Luci W. Hollingshead

Business Development: Mark Towner