Today's political briefing: Key developments
and analysis for Utah policymakers

Utah Policy Daily is a free newsletter published
business days by Utah Policy.com. Send us your
comments and ideas
. See our Policy Daily Archive.
Please forward this to friends.

Subscribe or Unsubscribe


Message Center

Advocacy Essay

Tax Cut or Transportation Projects?

It would be foolish to cut taxes in the upcoming legislative session while inadequately funding crucial transportation and economic development projects. Read entire essay


News Highlights

GOP National Committee Chairman Ken Mehlman visits Salt Lake, takes swipe at Rep. Jim Matheson (Salt Lake Tribune).

Sen. Chris Buttars plans to unveil bill challenging the teaching of evolution in public schools at annual Utah Eagle Forum convention (Deseret Morning News).

Utah one of only three states to give V.P. Dick Cheney an approval rating above 50 percent (Tribune).



Quote of the Day

“Come on, America. Wake up! I'm sick of it.”

-- Sen. Orrin Hatch, on the floor of the Senate, opposing an amendment that would tax oil company profits. He scolded Democrats for preventing new energy development, then complaining about high oil prices. (Tribune).



Thursday Buzz
Written by LaVarr Webb & Associates

How to Beat Jim Matheson: Use Flattery

Rep. Jim Matheson is sitting pretty in the 2nd Congressional District. But he’s beatable. Here’s how to do it: Flatter him. Appeal to his vanity. Tell him he’s Utah’s most popular politician. Read him those amazing poll numbers over and over again. Tell him Utahns love him. Tell him he’s so good he really ought to be a U.S. senator. Why toil amongst the House riffraff when the House of Lords awaits?

Entice him to run against Sen. Orrin Hatch. It would be a good battle, but Hatch would win. Matheson would win Salt Lake County, but Hatch would crush him in Utah and Davis counties. The headlines have said Matheson is the state’s most popular politician. But his rating was measured only in the 2nd District. If Matheson was tested statewide, it’s obvious that Gov. Jon Huntsman’s 76% approval rating would be ahead.  

Assuming Matheson doesn’t fall for the flattery, he’s looking really tough in the 2nd District with a half million dollars in the bank and a sky-high approval rating.

Christensen Certain to Run

By Mark E. Towner

I spoke with Rep. LaVar Christensen last night and he said he was absolutely going to run for the 2nd Congressional GOP nomination. He said he would be shortly transferring funds into a exploratory account, and make a formal announcement soon. He chuckled about the recent comments concerning KSL Radio host Doug Wright going to Washington D.C. and meeting with GOP leadership. Christensen said he made the same trip months ago, but chose not to make a big deal about it. So it appears it will be a two-person race between Wright and the Representative from Draper. This race as in the past will be a delegate chase for the elusive 60% at convention.

For the past two election cycles, John Swallow and Tim Bridgewater have battled each other, spending most of their money just seeking the GOP nomination, while Democrat Jim Matheson was able to sail to the general election with his campaign war chest intact. The main difference this cycle will be Christensen's deep-pocket ability to self-fund the hardest portion of any GOP nomination cycle: pre-convention. Christensen will appeal to conservative GOP delegates, having authored Amendment 3 on marriage. Even Democrat Matheson supported Amendment 3, but Wright did not. This may cause him trouble with delegates outside of Salt Lake County, especially northern Utah County, where support for the amendment was strong. Wright is solid on some other conservative issues, such as guns, and some Republicans also think a more moderate candidate is needed to defeat Matheson.

Publisher’s Opinion

Why Not Let Envirocare Expand?

I did a small amount of communications work for Envirocare under its previous ownership. In the process, I learned enough about the company to become a fan. I believe Envirocare is an excellent company that performs an outstanding service for Utah and the country. It provides hundreds of good-paying jobs, a lot of them high-tech, and it brings in hundreds of millions of dollars into Utah, contributing millions of dollars in taxes.

So what’s not to like about Envirocare? It’s safe, a lot safer than numerous other businesses out there, like oil refineries. It is an environmental company. It doesn’t create waste; it safely disposes of waste. Our way of life would be dramatically altered if firms like Envirocare didn’t provide a safe place to dispose of waste byproducts created in routine manufacturing processes. It also helps resolve long-standing environmental problems by disposing of contaminated dirt from neighborhoods and business districts.

Anyone who doesn’t like what Envirocare does is rather hypocritical if they take advantage of the modern conveniences of life. You can’t enjoy the lifestyle we lead and not create waste that must be disposed of safely.  

We ought to welcome and encourage Envirocare’s expansion, not forbid it. There’s a nice market for what it does and it’s good for Utah’s economy. The operation sits on a tiny amount of land, one square mile, in Utah’s vast west desert. Doubling its size wouldn’t even be noticed. Opposition to Envirocare is based on silly emotionalism, not on facts.

Mehlman Pays Utah a Visit

By Mark E. Towner

Ken Mehlman, Chair of the Republican National Committee, headlined a reception at the Grand America Hotel last night and spoke to a select group of Republicans called the Ronald Reagan Club. The club is the premier fundraising organization of the Utah GOP. The reception was held in a private lounge of the hotel and Mehlman spoke in front of a roaring fireplace. He walked easily around the room while talking and connected personally with the 30-40 people in attendance.

After talking about several current issues he pointed out a remarkable statistic. In 2004, during the last 72-hour get-out-the-vote effort, nearly 40% of the volunteers nationally that manned phones and pounded the pavement were members of the LDS Church. In response to a question on current attacks by Democrats concerning the Iraq war, Mehlman said President Bush would no longer sit back and allow Democrats to flip-flop on the issue, especially when their statements contradict comments made during the previous Clinton administration. He said Bush would respond aggressively to these political attacks, and that the GOP already has produced a video of these same Democrats saying that Iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction, and Saddam should be removed.

Washington Watch

Bishop Water Bill Passes Committee 

A bill sponsored by Rep. Rob Bishop designed to increase water supplies for Northern Utah passed the House Resources Committee Wednesday.  HR 3626 authorizes the Secretary of Interior to conduct a feasibility study on increasing the height and capacity of the Watkins Dam, which would make more water resources available as part of Willard Bay and the Weber Basin Project. "Everyone knows we need more water in Utah, and looking at increasing the height and capacity of this reservoir just makes sense," said Bishop in a press release. 

Hatch Pushes Pension Bill

Legislation passed by the Senate to strengthen and improve the nation’s private-pension system includes provisions pushed by Sen. Orrin Hatch "that would benefit employers in Utah." (See press release); Senate also passes resolution sponsored by Hatch that designates Nov. 17, the Thursday before Thanksgiving Day, as “Feed America Thursday.” Says Hatch: “Too many Americans suffer from hunger each day. Feed America Thursday gives all of us the opportunity to help those in need so no one will go hungry during this Thanksgiving season.” (See press release.)

Blog Watch

Rep. Steve Urquhart updates his previous post on repealing/mitigating the food tax... Pete Ashdown says new poll results on Sen. Orrin Hatch show "our efforts are paying off."... Third Party Watch notes the Julian Hatch candidacy, and a commenter says, "I’d love to be at the Hatch Thanksgiving Day dinner this year!"... On his blog, NewsMax.com columnist Steve Farrell congratulates Utah for taking a stand against the feds over NCLB.

U of U Students Debate Health Insurance

By Mark E. Towner 

In a meeting Wednesday at the Hinckley Institute of Politics, a panel discussed the problems facing the University regarding continued health insurance coverage for students. The U. has approximately 29,000 students enrolled; however, only 7% choose to purchase the student insurance. Before 1996, all students were required to be covered by insurance either by purchasing student insurance, or providing a certificate of insurance from another source like their parents’ family policy.

A proposed vote by the University’s Student Legislature (48 Representatives and 16 Senators) may suggest a mandatory requirement again. Panel members Jason Gillman, Tiffany Trinh, and Tek Kilgore indicated that the current system is unsustainable. “Out of every dollar collected in insurance, $1.06 is being paid out in services and administration costs” said Gillman. Mandatory insurance requirements are opposed by the College Republicans as stated by Brad Anderson. The College Democrats’ Remington Johnson indicated his caucus had not formally taken a position, but felt more information is needed. There will be additional public meetings around campus listed at www.ustudents.com . Different ideas were discussed, including raising student fees to cover basic healthcare coverage needs at the Student Health Services, and have the University Hospital Network offer a catastrophic policy within its own network. Regardless of what decision is made, doing nothing is not an option as the current insurance underwriter will simply drop coverage altogether as it is losing money on the current plan.



 

Thursday
November 17, 2005



National Headlines

Long story advocating need for light rail in Oakland County, Michigan, takes detailed look at public transit system along Utah's Wasatch Front and features comments by Robert Grow, Utah’s smart growth ambassador to the world (Metro Times Detroit).

Local Headlines

City Weekly

- Governor Guts, BlackBerry Blues, Downtown Livin'

- How history, along with Politics, fuels Utah's rural road wars and turns ATVs into a distraction

- Hatch Blows the Hatch

- Electoral Dysfunction II

- Editorial: Broken Records

Salt Lake Tribune

- Think Bush's numbers are low? Check out Cheney's

- Hatch pitches bill to address elder abuse

- Hatch resolution aims at feeding the hungry

- Rocky gets award for drug policy reform

- Churches' volunteers exemption under fire

- Rocky wants to offer free parking at meters to low-smog car models

- GOP top dog, in town for a fundraiser, takes a swipe at popular Matheson

- Student numbers put strain on schools

- Hatch blows his stack over the proposed tax on big oil

- House, group join to restore Topaz site

- South Salt Lake straightens out its beer license, Sunday sales laws

- Qwest wants to offer cable

- Report on Wal-Mart to banks: Watch your backs

- Editorial: Monster Homes: Amendments would protect character of older neighborhoods

Standard-Examiner

- Ogden takes next step for court

- Editorial: A well-deserved center

St. George Spectrum

- Education dominates legislative session

- Hildale votes down off-premise beer license

- County Democrats hold house party

Deseret Morning News

- Buttars plans a bill on evolution

- Clean fuel could earn free parking

- Pumping iron at the U of U and Westminster

- Shurtleff believes justices will back deity references

- Comcast protests Qwest cable plan

- Sp. Fork's slim loser seeks recount

- W. Jordan may create sewer fund

- UTA may run on soy power


Advocacy Essay:

Tax Cut or Transportation Projects?

(This essay was not requested or paid for by a particular client, but expresses the personal opinion of the author, LaVarr Webb, who does consulting work for the transportation industry and also for the USTAR initiative.)

Some legislators are talking about a $225 million tax cut next year. They would like to eliminate the sales tax on food and not replace the lost revenue. But with the state facing a $4 billion gap in revenue for crucial transportation projects over the next decade, cutting taxes by such a large amount doesn’t make sense. I agree with House Majority Leader Jeff Alexander’s position on this issue. He says it would be foolish to cut taxes now and then raise taxes later when the Legislature is forced to get serious about transportation shortfalls.

I fully agree with legislators who don’t want to build new revenue from Utah’s strong economy into base operating budgets that would be difficult to cut during lean times. So don’t put the new money into base budgets. Instead, spend it on badly-needed capital projects like transportation and infrastructure for the USTAR economic development initiative. These projects will keep the state’s economy humming and in lean times can be scaled back without laying off employees.  

Voters are not clamoring for a tax cut. Business leaders are not clamoring for a tax cut. Instead, they clearly want investment in transportation infrastructure and economic development tools such as USTAR. In 1990, Merrill Cook placed a proposal on the ballot to eliminate the sales tax on food. Voters turned it down. I’m certain that citizens would rather have less congestion on I-15 in Utah County than have a small tax cut. They would rather have a TRAX line into West Jordan and South Jordan or West Valley, than have a small tax cut. They would rather support research and development that spins off high-tech businesses with high-paying jobs, than have a small tax cut.

We’ll have a million more people along the Wasatch Front in the next 20 years. If we don’t start planning and building the transportation infrastructure right now to maintain mobility and keep the economy strong, our children and grandchildren will wonder why we failed them.


Political Calendar

Please submit calendar items to Daily@UtahPolicy.com

- Nov 17: Gov. Herbert to chair the Capitol Preservation Board Meeting, 9 am, Olmstead Conference Room at the Capitol.
- Nov 17: Gov. Huntsman KUED Monthly News Conference, 10 am, KUED studios.
- Nov 17: Gov. Huntsman to speak to the Utah Homebuilder's Association, 12 pm, The Gardner Village, 1100 W 7800 S., Salt Lake City.
- Nov 17: Constitutional Defense Council, 1 pm.
- Nov 17: Governor’s Monthly Declaration Signing, 1:40 pm, Governor’s Boardroom/Office.
- Nov 17: Hinckley Forum, "Should the U.S. Adopt Socialized Health Care?" 2 pm.
Raylene Ireland, former Executive Director of Administrative Services for the Department of Workforce Services; MPASA (Master of Public Administration Student Association).
- Nov 17: Lt. Gov. Herbert to participate in opening ceremony for the Rocky Mountain Testing Solutions, 3 pm, 4066 S 1900 W in Roy.
- Nov 17: Utah State Bar and Property Rights Ombudsman Seminars on Land Use Regulation for attorneys, real estate professionals, planners and citizens, 6:30 pm, Uintah County Commission Chambers, 147 E. Main Street, Vernal. Free or modest charge for materials or education credit. Questions call 801-731-5399 in Weber County. Details at www.utahbar.org/cle/events.
- Nov 17: Davis County Democrats Planning Meeting, 7 pm, County Commission Chambers
Farmington Memorial Courthouse, 28 E. State St. Farmington.
- Nov 18: Wasatch County Democratic Party Phone Network. To help contact Lisa Teifke at 435-785-7850 or lisa_f_teifke@fanniemae.com
- Nov 18: Lt. Gov. Herbert to keynote at the Annual Farm Bureau Convention, 2:20 pm, Downtown Marriott.
- Nov 18: Lt. Gov. to participate with LaVell Edwards in the Ascend Alliance Charity Event, 6 pm, Grand America's Oak Room.
- Nov 19: Republican Party State Central Committee Meeting, 8:30 am, Provo City Council Chambers.
- Nov 19: Lt. Gov. Herbert to speak at the Navy and Marine Corps Awards and Retirement Ceremony, 9 am, Ft. Douglas.

- Nov 19: Wasatch County Democratic Party Phone Network. To help contact Lisa Teifke at 435-785-7850 or lisa_f_teifke@fanniemae.com
- Nov 21: Lt. Gov. Herbert to chair the Homeland Security Advisory Council, 9 am, State Auditorium on Capitol Hill.

- Nov 21: Democrats of Southern Utah Luncheon, 11:30 am, Dixie Center 1835 Convention Center Drive. Pete Ashdown, candidate for U.S. Senate and Election of D of SU Officers.
- Nov 22: Administrative Rules Review Committee, 9 am, room W135.
- Nov 22: Lt. Gov. Herbert to speak at the Bear River AOG, 12 pm, 2400 North Main in Logan.

- See the entire calendar

Elected Officials Birthday List


Utah Policy Daily is a service
of Utah Policy.com

Publisher: LaVarr Webb
Editor: Paul Hollingshead
News: Golden Webb
Calendar and Subscriptions: Luci W. Hollingshead

Business Development: Mark Towner

 

Utah Policy Daily
American Plaza III, Suite 105
47 West 200 South
Salt Lake City, UT 84101
801.537.0900 Office
801.537.0901 Fax
801.502.9134 Cell 24/7