Today's political briefing: Key developments
and analysis for Utah policymakers
Subscribe or Unsubscribe

Message Center

(Announcements, Advertisements, Advertorials, and Sponsored Articles.)

Reader Response

More Support for Airport TRAX Line

Robert Farrington, director of the Salt Lake Chamber’s Downtown Alliance, wrote: “In addition to serving the customers of the airport and airlines, there are a considerable number of employees in and around the airport, including the International Center.  It is currently the second largest employment center in Utah.  Connecting that area with the largest employment center in Utah, downtown Salt Lake City, seems to make good planning and land use policy on those grounds alone.  Combined with the other benefits to local residents using the airport, as well as our important visitor and convention customers, makes the TRAX airport extension a high value opportunity.”

(See yesterday’s Advocacy Essay below on why it is important to build the airport TRAX line.)



 

News Highlights

Utah’s rainy day funds have hit their caps and are full; another big state surplus may mean tax cuts in upcoming legislative session forced by spending limitation caps (Deseret Morning News).

Article: "Utah's congressional delegation praised the Iraq Study Group's thoughtful recommendations Wednesday, but Sen. Orrin Hatch cautioned that America needs to stick with the fight, saying 'we can't go home losers.' Hatch said it was worthwhile to have the bipartisan panel study the issue, but reserved judgment on some recommendations, particularly the study group's key suggestion that combat troops be withdrawn by early 2008" (Salt Lake Tribune) (see also related KCPW and Morning News stories, and Morning News, Standard-Examiner, and Tribune editorials).

Quote of the Day

“Utah can ill-afford to lose teachers, some of whom are undoubtedly among the best and brightest, to neighboring states. Unfortunately, that's exactly what's happening.”

-- KSL Radio/TV editorial by Duane Cardall


 
Thursday Buzz
Written by LaVarr Webb & Associates

New Romney Community

Wade Eyerly e-mailed Utah Policy Daily to announce a new “e-community forming around Governor Mitt Romney and his potential candidacy.” Check it out at www.mittspaces.com.  

Eyerly said the site is a “new ‘spin’ on the myspace experience.” It features a lot of images and video, and supporters can sign up as “mittsters,” join discussion groups, etc. “This site is specifically built to help put Romney fans, or observers, in touch with other Romney fans,” Eyerly said.

High Oil Prices Not All Bad

Utah economist Jeff Thredgold’s Tea Leaf economic update newsletter this week focuses on energy issues. Thredgold predicts that oil prices will stay within a range of $50 to $65 a barrel. The Saudis do not want the price to go higher because it results in greater U.S. efforts at energy independence, which could hurt the Saudis and other major oil-producing nations in the long run. High oil prices aren’t all bad, Thredgold writes: “Prices north of $70.00 per barrel enhance the call for more urgent moves towards hybrid and electric cars, more rapid use of new clean-burning diesel powered cars, more rapid development of hydrogen cars, and greater utilization of wind, solar, and geothermal sources of energy. High oil prices boost investment and government subsidies for ethanol development in the Midwest, with more urgent planning to utilize corn, grasses, weeds, and methane to generate energy.”

Washington Watch

Hatch: New Ideas Needed on Iraq

Sen. Orrin Hatch says of the recently released report prepared by the Iraq Study Group: "We clearly needed a fresh look at a very difficult situation, and I'm looking forward to reading the report in detail. This is the first of several reports -- including proposals being developed by the Joint Chiefs of Staff and the National Security Council -- that will give the Administration new ideas on how we can obtain our goals in Iraq" (see press release).

Bennett: Next Year for Lands Bill?

Sen. Bob Bennett announces that the Washington Co. lands bill he co-sponsored with Rep. Jim Matheson has stalled in the 109th Congress and that he will look to next year for passage. Says Bennett: "I believe we had enough support in the Senate to pass this bill, but given the post-election environment in the House, it became clear they would not act on it, or many other pending bills, before they adjourn. Washington County will continue to experience unprecedented growth, and it is unfortunate that efforts to help address this will be delayed. I want to thank Congressman Matheson for his partnership in this initiative, and look forward to continuing this work in the new Congress" (see press release).

National Politics

Hillary Campaign Humming

Washington Post story says Sen. Hillary Clinton is ramping up her presidential campaign machine.

Wise Words

“If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it costs when it’s free.”

-- P.J. O’Rourke, civil libertarian

SUWA: White River Plan Draws Opposition

The Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance announces that the BLM's Vernal field office "has received more that 30,000 public comments in opposition to a plan to drill more than 50 natural gas wells on federal and state lands just south of Utah's White River." Says SUWA attorney Stephen Bloch: "BLM needs to consider the impacts that this project -- along with several others under consideration or recently approved by the agency -- will have to the White River in a comprehensive environmental impact statement. As currently planned, this project and others will change the face of the White River for generations and leave a legacy of blighted lands, dirtied skies, and polluted waters" (see press release).


Blog Watch
Rep. Steve Urquhart says: "I tire of reading editorials that Democrats are not 'allowed' to participate in legislative decisions. Of course, such editorials are intended to bolster the theme that Republicans are bad. But, at its core, such whining merely demeans Democrat legislators. In the House, there are 75 representatives; any 38 of them can pass out a bill. In the Senate, there are 29 senators; any 15 of them can pass out a bill. Elections and the Constitution of Utah give each legislator all the permission he/she needs to participate. To argue that a Democrat legislator is incapable of getting anything done, other than as a product of Republican magnanimity, is false. Any legislator, Democrat or Republican, simply needs to work with others and build coalitions. I don't recall Rep. Brad King ever begging for anyone's permission to participate. I see him and other effective legislators jumping in and doing what it takes to get things done. Any legislator, Democrat or Republican, who thinks success should be delivered up just because he/she is louder, purer, smarter, entitled, or sympathetic, is going to waste a lot of time pouting -- while more effective legislators will be out working to build coalitions.The whining must sell newspapers, but it is dumb and it dumbs down the dialogue, doing the public a disservice".... Paul Rolly reports: "Some Utah legislators [were] grumbling [yesterday] that it seems like more than a coincidence that congressional leaders decided not to consider Utah's fourth House seat during its lame duck special session.” (see also here and here).... Hotline On Call says: "The Fix's Chris Cillizza reports that Gov. Mitt Romney has retained the services of Matt Rhoades, the former research director of the RNC. Rhoades will be a senior communications strategist and probably serve the campaign as communications director. He'll work closely with Kevin Madden, brought on to be the national spokesman. Rhoades was the research director for Bush-Cheney '04. He kept the Kerry portfolio. Whatever Kerry said, Rhoades knew the ten things he'd say next. With Steve Schmidt, he ran the campaign's famous rapid-response warroom. Campaign officials credit him with doing more than just about any other staffer to define John Kerry as weak, wimpy, French and flip-floppy -- an unacceptable Commander in Chief. And now, he'll handle a larger portfolio, designing a communications strategy and overseeing research against opponents Republican and Democrat. You won't see Rhoades quoted by name, and he rarely talks to the press. But Republican insiders say he has a preternatural understanding of news cycles and the folkways of the establishment (and non-establishment) media. And as Cillizza reports, he has a direct line to Matt Drudge, who can still (despite some slippage) drive network news coverage. Finally, he's one of the best opposition researchers in the business" (see also here, here, and here).

 

Elected Officials Birthday List


Utah Policy Daily is a service
of Utah Policy.com

Publisher: LaVarr Webb
Editor: Paul Hollingshead
News: Golden Webb
Calendar and Subscriptions: Luci Hollingshead

 

Utah Policy Daily
American Plaza III, Suite 105
47 West 200 South
Salt Lake City, UT 84101
801.537.0900 Office
801.537.0901 Fax

 

Special E-Mail Messages: Utah Policy Daily may send subscribers e-mails with information about new features, special offers, or messages on public policy issues from clients and advertisers. If you do not wish to ever receive these e-mails, please let us know by e-mail at daily@utahpolicy.com.


 

Thursday
December 7, 2006


Utah in the National News

Article: "A day after the Republican-led Utah Legislature approved a package aimed at creating two new seats in Congress, one for Utah and one for the District of Columbia, Republican leaders in Congress said the plan was dead and would not be voted on this session. A spokesman for the chief backer of the plan, Representative Thomas M. Davis III, Republican of Virginia, said Mr. Davis would push for reconsideration. Failing that, the spokesman said, Mr. Davis would reintroduce the package in the next Congress, which the Democrats will lead. A spokesman for Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr. of Utah, a Republican, said Mr. Huntsman had not given up either and was making calls on Tuesday to Washington in an effort to keep the idea alive. 'We're disappointed, but we view this as a temporary setback, not by any means a final decision,' said the spokesman, Mike Mower" (New York Times) (see also related Washington Post and Associated Press stories).


Mitt Romney Watch
Columnist/talk show host Michael Graham says: "As a South Carolina GOP political consultant in a past life, I am forever asked whether 'your people' will vote for 'one of them.' Translation: Will South Carolina evangelicals vote for a Mormon? .... Yes, it's true that most evangelicals do not consider Mormons Christians. Yes, many would even classify Mormonism as a cult. But in America today, where religion and faith are under constant media assault, the question evangelical voters are asking isn't 'Christian vs. Jew' or 'Methodist vs. Mormon,' but rather 'God or no God?' For values voters, the battle is between people who value faith and those who either ignore it or are actively hostile toward it. [Mitt] Romney is an ally to evangelicals not because he is or isn't a Christian, but because he's a conservative who believes in God and takes his faith seriously. Mormonism also benefits from the positive behavior of its members. Mormon teachings -- magic rocks and golden tablets and Jesus roaming Utah with a lost Indian tribe -- may strike evangelicals as a bit loony, but from a lifestyle standpoint, the only different between Mitt Romney and a southern Baptist is that Romney really will turn down a free drink" (Boston Herald) (see additional Romney coverage in New York Observer and The Phoenix stories and Boston Globe op-ed).


Local Headlines

Salt Lake Tribune

- Hatch: We can't go home losers

- Iraq Report highlights

- First family hopes for an addition

- Sewer district moratorium called 'a crisis'

- UDOT awards 3 contracts for Legacy Parkway work

- South S.L.'s Babka may swap badges

- House passes bill to allow tithing during bankruptcy

- RSL misses deadline to open up books

- Plan would put schools chief in Cabinet spot

- Forest management petition pulled back

- Advisers tell state to buy meds for flu pandemic

- German city beats SLC for crime-fighting award

- Delta CEO vows to fend off takeover

- Editorial: Let it die: Give up on ill-advised Washington County bill

- Editorial: Responsible transition: Iraq Study Group points the way

Standard-Examiner

- Powder Mountain development on hold

- Editorial: Heed advice on Iraq

KCPW

- Green Groups to Continue Fight Against Stalled Wash Co Land Bill

- Huntsman Tries Again on All-Day K

- Provo Officials Refute Negative Report of iProvo

- Legislature to Take Another Look at School Nursing Shortage

- Topaz Could See Millions from Congress for Restoration

- Creative Solutions Required for Future Water Needs

- Matheson Welcomes Iraq Study Group Report

- Utah Rivers Council hoping Legislature makes Water Conservation a Priority

- Money is Now the Hurdle for "Adam Galvez Street"

City Weekly

- Hits & Misses

- Dead Watchdogs: Is anyone left to keep an eye on Utah lawmakers?

- Cabin Fever: Utah's gay Republicans still hope for a place at the GOP table

- Editorial: What You Know: Or who you know? Or how long you studied to know what you know? Either way, Utah isn't as educated as it used to be

St. George Spectrum

- Local leaders react to shelved bills

- CICWCD looks at budget for 2007

- County leaders look at wildland fires

BYU NewsNet

- Western Primary Could Entice Presidential Hopefuls

Daily Herald

- Provo moves $1.9M in excess money for capital improvements

- Lawmakers consider funding for school nurses

- Lindon council rescinds law regulating door-to-door sales

KSL Editorial Board

- Prevent Education Decline

Deseret Morning News

- Changes on Iraq crucial, panel says

- Officials split on teacher gun class

- Couple didn't defraud district, attorney says

- Surplus poses problem

- Plea made for nurses in schools

- Utah 6th healthiest state — down from 4th

- Real S.L. to release financial data Monday

- Schools may add 'critical need' languages

- S.L. justice program a finalist for award

- South S.L. chief may get undersheriff job

- Union Pacific hauling record coal from Wyoming and Utah

- Utah petroleum marketers tout drop in state's prices

- Editorial: Chart new course in Iraq


Political Calendar

Please submit calendar items to Daily@UtahPolicy.com

- Dec 7: Utah Technology Council seminar "Leveraging New Media: True Tales from the Utah Trenches," 7:30 to 9:30 a.m., University of Phoenix, 5373 Green St., Room 105. Cost is $10 for UTC members and $20 for non-UTC members.  The seminar is on on blogging as a corporate communications tool. Susan Richards of Altiris and Noelle Bates of Logoworks will present lessons learned and strategy recommendations on how to leverage blogging in corporate communications.
- Dec 7: Midday Metro at 10 a.m. on KCPW 88.3 FM features KUED producer Liz Searles and WWII historian Geoffrey Panos about the final episode of the public television station’s Emmy Award-winning series Utah WWII Stories. And Bill Brunson of the Phoenix IRS Office and Charlie Roberts of the Utah State Tax Commission offer last minute tax savings for 2006 as well as changes to consider for 2007. To participate, email midday@kcpw.org.
- Dec 7: RadioWest on KUER FM 90: "Witness in Palestine," 11 a.m. and 7 p.m. Anna Baltzer is a Jewish American woman, the granddaughter of a Holocaust survivor. Baltzer will talk about her book Witness in Palestine: Journal of a Jewish American Woman in the Occupied Territories.
- Dec 7: PRW (Professional Republican Women) Holiday Event, 11:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m., Governor's Mansion. Lunch will be catered by Panache. Guests are welcome. Cost is $35.00 with a tour of the mansion after the event optional at 2 p.m. RSVP by November 30 to make the mansion security list; bring picture ID. Call Melanie to RSVP at
801-891-6926 or email at melmrogers@yahoo.com.
- Dec 7: Davis County Democrats Planning Committee meeting, 7 p.m., Davis County Courthouse room 114, 28 East State Street, Farmington. Agenda includes discussion of President's Day Dinner, Davis County Convention, Constitution Essay Contest, and a report from the Phoenix Committee.  Legislative District Chairpersons and all interested democrats are urged to attend this meeting.
- Dec 8: Midday Metro at 10 a.m. on KCPW 88.3 FM features Salt Lake County Mayor Peter Corroon on the county budget, Real Salt Lake, and replacing trees along the Jordan River. Plus, homeless advocate Pamela Atkinson and Matt Minkevitch of The Road Home on the crisis facing Utah’s homeless population this winter and ways for you to make a difference. To participate, email midday@kcpw.org during the show.
- Dec 9: Davis County Democrats monthly breakfast, 8:30 a.m., Granny Annie's Restaurant, 286 North 400 West, Kaysville. Don't forget to bring your "Shoe Box for Veterans" and your nonperishable food donation for the Davis County Food Bank.

- See the entire calendar




 

 

 


Feature Story


Airport TRAX Line Makes Sense

By LaVarr Webb

The proposed TRAX light rail line from downtown SLC to the Salt Lake International Airport has been the subject of some controversy and concern. Critics who don’t much like rail transit to begin with, especially don’t like the airport line, saying it is too expensive and isn’t needed because congestion isn’t all that bad between downtown and the airport.

On the other side, polls show that of the four proposed new lines (to the airport, West Valley City, South Jordan and Draper), the airport line is the most popular of all with the general public. All four lines are ready to build if funded through the quarter-cent sales tax authorized by Proposition 3 in the recent election.

The airport line is particularly liked by residents of Salt Lake County’s east side and by people across the Wasatch Front who fly frequently from the airport. It is also important for the 13,000 people who work in the vicinity of the airport, virtually all of whom commute to work.

To view the line as simply a means to get from downtown to the airport is to miss its real value. The freeways may not be terribly crowded between the airport and downtown, but they are dreadfully crowded in Davis County, Utah County, and south Salt Lake County. Workers and travelers all across the Wasatch Front, from Ogden to Provo and from the western spurs in West Valley and South Jordan, will be able to hop a FrontRunner or TRAX train to the intermodal hub, then make a quick transfer to the airport.

So it’s not just a line from downtown to the airport. It is a line fed by the rest of the system, allowing a Sandy resident to be dropped off at a Sandy TRAX station and get to the airport in comfort -- reading, working on a laptop, or making phone calls along the way. Even workers and travelers in locations not served directly by TRAX or FrontRunner (such as Brigham City or Nephi) could drive to a park-and-ride lot in Ogden or Provo and take the train from there, avoiding traffic congestion and all the parking costs and hassles (such as waiting for a shuttle) at the airport.

In Washington, D.C., the Metro line to Washington National Airport is enormously convenient, fast, cheap—and popular. I much prefer using it to taking a cab or renting a car.

As far as cost, the airport line might actually be one of the more cost-effective projects because the airport itself is expected to contribute significantly to the cost. Projected ridership numbers are admittedly low, but that’s because the Utah Transit Authority must use conservative federal models to project ridership. Actual ridership on existing lines is triple the numbers projected. The airport line, fed by the rest of the system, will most certainly exceed projections very quickly.

The northwest quadrant of the city is poised for enormous growth. Major developments are planned by the LDS Church and Kennecott Land. These landowners are highly supportive of the airport line as a means to serve businesses and homeowners in these new developments. The line will also help revitalize the city’s North Temple corridor.

All in all, the airport line makes enormous good sense. I’m betting it will quickly become highly popular with workers and travelers all over the Wasatch Front, a focal point for the entire transit system.

 
 

On the Move

Links to the Week's Key Transportation News Stories

-- Editorial: Traffic just might be the resorts' toughest challenge this season (Park Record).

-- UDOT seeks input on Mountain View roads (Deseret Morning News).

-- Op-ed: Howard Stephenson: Pork projects hinder highways (Morning News).

-- Editorial: Victory for commuters (Baltimore Sun).

-- Ogden's Big Ride (Standard-Examiner).

-- S.R. 248 traffic misery spreads (Park Record).

-- Delta Air Lines to add Salt Lake-to-Charlotte service (Deseret Morning News).

-- Delta adding flights to Guadalajara (Salt Lake Tribune).

-- Provo plans airport upgrades (Daily Herald).

-- 2 new nonstops from Salt Lake City to Mexico (Associated Press).

-- Riding route 22: Passengers cross paths on the State Street bus (Morning News).

-- 5 at U. are winners with bus-stop design (Morning News).

-- Provo seeking I-15 connector to airport (Associated Press).

-- Op-ed: Nix to TRAX: More roads the solution to traffic congestion (Tribune).

-- Lindon opens 2-lane road (Deseret Morning News).

-- Open house planned on Redwood Rd. plans (Morning News).

-- Could trolleys stage a comeback in Ogden? (Standard-Examiner).

-- Lawmaker is pleased with transportation project plan (Salt Lake Tribune).

-- Will adjustment in proposed route fly? (Tribune).

-- SLC backs Delta as it fights offer of takeover (Tribune).


HNTB is a multidisciplinary firm known and respected for our work in transportation, bridges, aviation, architecture, urban design and planning, environmental engineering, water and construction services. We serve our clients with integrity, technical excellence and a commitment to performance— providing quality work, on time, on budget and to the client's satisfaction.

At HNTB, we're committed to providing an environment where our people can be successful, and where they can create infrastructure that exceeds the expectations of our clients and the communities they serve. Through exceptional service and a shared vision, we create public infrastructure that unites, enriches and inspires.

Visit HNTB's website here.



Utah Transportation Watch is a service of Utah Policy.com