Today's political briefing: Key developments
and analysis for Utah policymakers
Subscribe or Unsubscribe

Message Center

Announcements, Advertisements, Advertorials, and Sponsored Articles

Transportation Watch

Road Tolls and P3s Out of Favor?

There is little talk these days among Utah leaders about toll roads or public-private partnerships (P3s) in which private investment dollars are used to build highways. At the national level, the trend toward public-private partnerships has also waned.

Just a year or two ago there was a great deal of discussion about the Mountain View Corridor being built as a toll road or in partnership with private investors. But a couple of years of large budget surpluses, allowing significant investment in Mountain View and other highway projects, plus an effective anti-tolling campaign conducted by truckers and west side leaders who formed a coalition called Utahns for Safe and Efficient Transportation, have all but eliminated serious discussion about tolling.

At the national level, the new Congress controlled by the Democrats is highly skeptical of public-private partnerships. (Read full article below.)



 

News Highlights

Educating undocumented Utah students costs between $54.9 million and $85.4 million a year in federal, state, and local funding, according to a new legislative audit (Deseret Morning News, KCPW, and Salt Lake Tribune).

Long-time Transportation Commission member Glen Brown will be replaced as chair by Commission newcomer Stuart Adams (Tribune and Morning News).

Utah AG Mark Shurtleff will argue before Congress today that legislation giving Utah a 4th congressional seat is constitutional (Tribune).

Quote of the Day

"This is a country where one bullet can make a big difference."

-- John Bolton, former U.N. ambassador, speaking about the threat of assassination in Pakistan. He delivered a blunt speech to Utah business executives attending the Zions Bank International Trade and Business Conference (Tribune.) See also Morning News story.


Wednesday Buzz
Written by LaVarr Webb & Associates

Washington Watch

Hatch: 'More Positive' on Iraq

Sen. Orrin Hatch returns from a trip to Iraq and says, "[a] lot has changed ... When I was there a year ago -- the day the parliament was finally convened -- there was a real sense that the security situation was slipping backward. I came back from this trip with a more positive view of the overall situation" (see press release). 

Cannon: Don’t Tax the Internet

Rep. Chris Cannon released the following statement after a hearing on the “Internet Tax Freedom Act: Internet Tax Moratorium”:  “Keeping internet commerce and access free from discriminatory taxes has been good for the American economy.  Nothing stifles creativity, innovation, and prosperity like government intervention, especially taxes.  ‘If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.’  The internet is proof that competition and the free market create superior products and services, at lower costs.  The best thing Congress can do is stay out of the way.”

Today in Political History

May 23, 1788:  South Carolina is admitted as the 8th U.S. state.

May 23, 1838:  General Winfield Scott orders the forced relocation of the Cherokee Indians to the "Indian Nation" (now Oklahoma). About one-forth of the 10,000 Cherokees died in this march, called "The Trail of Tears”.

May 23, 1934: Bank robbers Bonnie Parker and Clyde Barrow are shot to death in a police ambush as they were driving a stolen Ford Deluxe along a road in Bienville Parish, La. (Source: New York Times www.nytimes.com)

May 23. 2000:  President Bill Clinton issues an Executive Order requiring that at least 5 percent of all federal procurements go to women-owned business. (Source:  perspicuity

Wise Words

“As to Taxes, they are evidently inseparable from Government. It is impossible without them to pay the debts of the nation, to protect it from foreign danger, or to secure individuals from lawless violence and rapine.”

-- Alexander Hamilton, Address to the Electors of the State of New York, 1801 (Source:  Patriot Post

Campaign Tip

What is Distributed Campaigning?

“Distributed campaigning” is an adaptation of the term “distributed computing,” which is defined as “the use of multiple computers networked throughout a wide geographical area to solve a single problem.” Distributed Computing was popularized by the SETI@Home Project in which at-home users could set up their computers to assist the SETI project when they were not otherwise in use. The home computers would automatically download sets of data to work on, process them and send the result back to the main SETI servers.

In Distributed Campaigning, political campaigns likewise maximize their power and impact through Internet-based tools that allow supporters to easily assist the campaign from their homes. For example, via the web, volunteers could download lists of voters, call them, and send the results back to the campaigns’ website.  (Read the entire tip by Benjamin Katz at Complete Campaigns.   

National Politics

Best Stories From . . .

-- Washington Post: "The Senate voted [Monday] night to move forward on an overhaul of immigration laws, but even proponents of the delicate compromise proposal conceded that the furor over the deal was surpassing their expectations and endangering the plan" (see also related Thomas Sowell and Froma Harrop columns, Kay Bailey Hutchinson and John Cornyn op-ed, and Economist editorial).

-- Des Moines Register: Columnist David Ypsen: "Two new Iowa Polls published Sunday indicate the big story to come out of the Iowa caucuses next January could be the defeats of the early national front-runners in both parties."

-- Zogby International: Pollster John Zogby: "It's time to deal with it. Could it be possible that the top contenders for President in 2008 are not even running just yet? Will Al Gore jump in and take the Democratic nomination? Is Newt Gingrich really going to run? Will Mike Bloomberg once again prove the greatness of this country: any man with a dream and a billion dollars can reach great heights?"

-- Los Angeles Times: "Flanked by local Latino leaders and a large contingent of politicians from his home state, New Mexico Gov. Bill Richardson formally entered the 2008 presidential campaign Monday, saying that his thick resume offered him an ability unmatched by others in the race to tackle the country's problems at home and abroad" (see also related CBS News story).

Lighter Side

Question of the Day: If a vegetarian eats vegetables, what does a humanitarian eat?

 

Journalistic Oops of the Day: "A front-page article yesterday about the role that Barack Obama's wife, Michelle, is playing in his presidential campaign rendered incorrectly a word in a quotation from Valerie Jarrett, a friend of the Obamas who commented on their decision that he would run. She said in a telephone interview, 'Barack and Michelle thought long and hard about this decision before they made it'--not that they 'fought' long and hard."--correction, New York Times, May 19 (Source: OpinionJournal’s Best of the Web)

 

 

Wednesday
May 23, 2007


Utah in the National News

Article: "Utah joined five other states and British Columbia on Monday in a pledge to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, although details on how they will do it are incomplete. Gov. Jon Huntsman signed the Western Regional Climate Action Initiative and joined other governors in criticizing the federal government for failing to reduce emissions that contribute to global warming. 'We're leading the charge. We're not waiting for Washington anymore. I suspect that Congress and Washington will pay attention at some point,' Huntsman said" (Associated Press) (see also related Reuters story).

Mitt Romney Watch

Article: "For Mitt Romney ... all is going according to plan. With an eye-popping $21 million raised in the first quarter of this year for his presidential campaign and a steady stream of television advertising, the one-term former governor of Massachusetts has caught the attention of both voters and political insiders. Star turns at the first two Republican debates gave his candidacy yet another shot of credibility. And now, recent polls in the early-voting states of Iowa and New Hampshire show Romney surging with a double-digit lead over Sen. John McCain of Arizona and former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani" (Chicago Tribune) (for more on Romney, see Washington Post and Hartford Courant stories and Byron York column).


Local Headlines

Salt Lake Tribune

- Granite district study flawed, superintendent tells board

- Please feed the zoo, Hogle says

- Transportation chief gets a call: Step aside

- Delegation from China courts Utah businesses

- Amendment may hinder prosecutor-firings probe

- Millions spent on off-books students

- 5 schools fail to heed endowment fund law, audit shows

- Rolly: Businesses score car for student

- Hatch sees improvement in Iraq during visit

- Shurtleff to testify move constitutional

- County officials stand behind voting machines

- Bolton blunt about world affairs

- Editorial: Legacy bypass: Don't repeat environmental planning mistakes

Standard-Examiner

- Officials pan voting mandate

- Editorial: Make good on the promise

Logan Herald Journal

- County gears up for 150th anniversary

St. George Spectrum

- Iron County to review water plan

- Council discusses budget

- Editorial: Growth aspects with TND

Tooele Transcript Bulletin

- Editorial: Track putting Tooele on the map; next step is ours

Davis County Clipper

- Parents to Burningham: Implement voucher program now

- Freeway bypass road proposed for S. Davis

Daily Herald

- Voting machines: Already junk?

- Lehi readies freeway connector protest

- Grandview meeting

- Payson eyes land for annexation

Park Record

- Controversial Party chair is out

KCPW

- Extra November Election Costs Likely to Fall on State and Counties

- Audit Claims High Cost of Illegal Immigrants on Utah Schools

- Hatch Says Progress Is Being Made In Iraq

Deseret Morning News

- Schooling illegals costly

- McCain, Romney jab back and forth

- Utah leads nation in supersized homes

- Voting-machine bill worries Utahns

- East district would struggle, Granite says

- School may get new life in Provo plan

- Huntsman names Transportation chief

- Hatch observes progress in Iraq

- Hogle bond questioned

- W. Jordan approves firm for school district study

- Op-ed: Amnesty for illegals isn't answer

- Editorial: Energy policy a federal case


Political Calendar

Please submit calendar items to Daily@UtahPolicy.com

- May 23: Governor Huntsman to attend the IKEA Grand Opening, 8:25 a.m., Draper.
- May 23: Local Issues Task Force, 9 a.m., room W110.
- May 23: KCPW Intelligence Squared debate "Hollywood Has Feuled Anti-Americanism Abroad," 10 a.m., KCPW 88.3 FM. For more info visit http://www.intelligencesquaredus.org.

- May 24: ACLU of Utah Annual Bill of Rights Celebration, Salt Lake City. Special guests include Chris Finan, President of the American Booksellers Foundation for Free Expression and The Salt Lake Tribune editorial cartoonist Pat Bagley. For more info about the Bill of Rights Celebration or to order your tickets, please visit www.acluutah.org or call 801-521-9862 ext 101.
- May 24: Senator Carlene Walker's Walker Cup Golf Tournament, Old Mill Golf Course.  Registration begins at 6:30 a.m., shotgun start at 7:30 a.m.  Please call 801-733-4599 for more information.
- May 24: Governor Huntsman's KUED Monthly News Conference, 10 a.m., KUED Studios.
- May 24: Administrative Rules Review Committee, 2 p.m., room W135.
- May 24: KSL's "Let Me Speak to the Governor," 6 p.m., KSL Studios.
- May 24: Salt Lake County Libertarian Party Meeting, 7 p.m., Grecian Garden, 4816 South State Street, Murray. For more information, visit http://www.lputah.org.
- May 24: Governor Huntsman to attend the Zions Bank Hispanic Small Business Awards Ceremony, 7:30 p.m., The Grand America Hotel, Salt Lake City.

- May 25-27: Democratic National Committee Western Caucus
- May 26: Utah for Obama Organizing Meeting, 2 p.m., Conference Room C, Level -1, Salt Lake City Library, 210 East 400 South. Utah for Obama is a grassroots group of supporters of Barack Obama's Presidential Campaign. The biweekly meeting is open to the public. To RSVP, or for more info, contact Misty Fowler at admin@UtahForObama .org.
- May 30: KCPW Intelligence Squared debate "A Democratically Elected Hamas is Still a Terrorist Organization," 10 a.m., KCPW 88.3 FM. For more info visit http://www.intelligencesquaredus.org.
- May 30: The George Washington Center for Freedom and Understanding presents an evening with President Lech Walesa, President of Poland from 1990-1995 and Nobel Prize for Peace in 1983, the Grand America Ballroom, Salt Lake City. Tickets: $250 per plate, $2000 per table of ten, $7500 photo reception and table of ten. To attend email con@gwcfreedom.org or call 202-536-2938.

- See the entire calendar


Elected Officials Birthday List


Utah Policy Daily is a service
of Utah Policy.com

Publisher: LaVarr Webb
Editor: Paul Hollingshead
News: Golden Webb
Calendar and Subscriptions: Luci Hollingshead

 

Utah Policy Daily
Crandall Building, Suite 300
10 West 100 South
Salt Lake City UT 84101
801.537.0900 Office
801.537.0901 Fax

 

Special E-Mail Messages: Utah Policy Daily may send subscribers e-mails with information about new features, special offers, or messages on public policy issues from clients and advertisers. If you do not wish to ever receive these e-mails, please let us know by e-mail at daily@utahpolicy.com.




 

 

 


Feature Story


Road Tolls and P3s Out of Favor?

By LaVarr Webb

There is little talk these days among Utah leaders about toll roads or public-private partnerships (P3s) in which private investment dollars are used to build highways. At the national level, the trend toward public-private partnerships has also waned.

Just a year or two ago there was a great deal of discussion about the Mountain View Corridor being built as a toll road or in partnership with private investors. But a couple of years of large budget surpluses, allowing significant investment in Mountain View and other highway projects, plus an effective anti-tolling campaign conducted by truckers and west side leaders who formed a coalition called Utahns for Safe and Efficient Transportation, have all but eliminated serious discussion about tolling.

At the national level, the new Congress controlled by the Democrats is highly skeptical of public-private partnerships. While the Bush administration has encouraged such financing arrangements, the chairs of Congress’s Transportation & Infrastructure Committee and its Highways & Transit subcommittee (Democrats James Oberstar and Peter DeFazio, respectively) sent a letter to all 50 state governors and other officials warning them not to enter into P3 agreements that “can undermine the national highway system.” And in Texas, which has led the nation in P3 development, there has been an uprising of citizens against tolling, and state legislators passed and sent to the governor a two-year moratorium on any new P3 deals.

In Utah, so long as funding exists to build highways without raising taxes or tolling, it is unlikely tolling will gain much traction. But if the big budget surpluses dry up and funding for desperately-needed highways is non-existent, then choices between tolling and tax increases will have to be made.

Meanwhile, one specific form of tolling, allowing citizens to purchase permits to drive in the HOV lane on I-15, is proving to be a major success for UDOT. Anyone who drives on I-15 is benefited if use of high-occupancy vehicle lanes is maximized. It means less congestion in other lanes.

Far from being “Lexus lanes,” the HOT lane permit purchasers are mostly average Utahns who prefer to pay a little extra to avoid congestion. Even better, UDOT is considering upgrading to an electronic HOT lanes system, which likely means even more people will be able to obtain transponders and pay only when they use the HOV lane, instead of being charged a flat monthly permit fee. Of course, the main purpose of the HOV lane concept, to encourage people to carpool, will remain intact. Vehicles carrying two or more people will always be able to use the HOV lane free of charge.

 
 
 

On the Move

Links to the Week's Key Transportation News Stories

-- Salt Lake County finds less money for road projects (Salt Lake Tribune).

-- Tax dollars going toward nearly $1 million in projects (Davis County Clipper).

-- Proposal to merge UTA with UDOT is brought back (Salt Lake Tribune and Deseret Morning News).

-- Woods Cross residents worry about UTA rail station plan (Tribune).

Ogden-Hinckley Airport to expand (KSL).

-- Delta adds 35 direct flights out of Salt Lake (Park Record).

-- Council approves parkway widening plan (St. George Spectrum).

-- Interchange bypass road proposed for Davis County (Salt Lake Tribune).  

-- New Legacy land plan drawing fire (Deseret Morning News).

-- Possible light for Redwood (Davis County Clipper).

-- Jordan trail crossing to get a tunnel (Daily Herald).

-- Editorial: Don't dismantle UTA (Deseret Morning News).

-- Fliers on UTA redesign irk riders (Deseret Morning News).

-- Bus route changes nearing final approval (KCPW).

-- Residents living near train tracks beg for quiet (Associated Press).


HNTB is a multidisciplinary firm known and respected for our work in transportation, bridges, aviation, architecture, urban design and planning, environmental engineering, water and construction services. We serve our clients with integrity, technical excellence and a commitment to performance— providing quality work, on time, on budget and to the client's satisfaction.

At HNTB, we're committed to providing an environment where our people can be successful, and where they can create infrastructure that exceeds the expectations of our clients and the communities they serve. Through exceptional service and a shared vision, we create public infrastructure that unites, enriches and inspires.

Visit HNTB's website here.



Utah Transportation Watch is a service of Utah Policy.com