Today's political briefing: Key developments
and analysis for Utah policymakers
Subscribe or Unsubscribe

Message Center

Announcements, Advertisements, Advertorials, and Sponsored Articles

Transportation Watch

MVC and Air Pollution Concerns

The Sierra Club is mounting an attack on the Mountain View Corridor, arguing it shouldn’t be built until mass transit, such as light rail, is provided along the corridor. Its latest tactic is to claim that the highway will pollute the air and be unhealthy for children in nearby schools.

The long-range plan for the corridor does include mass transit, but not immediately. The obvious reason that UDOT, Wasatch Front Regional Council, Utah Transit Authority, etc., did not propose mass transit ahead of the highway is that ridership would initially be too low to justify the investment. As the population booms along the corridor over the next 20 or 30 years, mass transit will be developed to meet the needs. But the highway is clearly needed first.

The worst automobile pollution occurs when cars are in gridlock, pumping out fumes while at a standstill on narrow streets and on I-15, I-215 and Bangerter Highway. The Mountain View Corridor will help alleviate gridlock valley-wide and especially in the western valley areas. (Read full article, below)



 

News Highlights

-- SLC Council adopts $202 million budget (Salt Lake Tribune and Deseret Morning News).

-- Rocky Anderson nearly gets in a fistfight with a major downtown developer, who says he won't do business with Salt Lake City until Anderson is out of office (Morning News, Logan Herald Journal, and Tribune).

Quote of the Day

“This is not good for kids.”

-- Julene Jolley, Granite School Board member, reacting to a study showing negative impacts of a school district split, both on the east side and west side (Tribune).  


Wednesday Buzz
Written by LaVarr Webb & Associates

Washington Watch

Hatch: Gonzales Resolution Sends Wrong Message

In op-ed, Sen. Orrin Hatch says: "There is much to criticize about how some U.S. attorneys were removed last year. But the Senate's no-confidence resolution is the wrong way to send the wrong message about the attorney general's service. Months of hearings and investigations have yielded no real evidence that U.S. attorneys were removed for truly improper reasons. The nation's business waits while this fishing expedition continues. ... Inappropriate resolutions that send misleading messages will not solve the nation's real pressing problems. We should move on" (USA Today) (see also related Hatch press release and Washington Post story); Hatch introduces legislation that would reduce gasoline prices by increasing the capacity of American oil refineries (press release).

Matheson: Growing Passport Problem

Rep. Jim Matheson sends a letter to the Secretary of State asking what specific actions are being planned to address the problem of backlogged passport applications. Says Matheson: "The Department has issued several statements indicating that it has regained control of the situation, but the growing numbers of phone calls and complaints from our constituents indicates otherwise. During the two weeks before and after Memorial Day, my office fielded over seventy requests for assistance with passports" (see press release).

Today in Political History

June 13, 1966:  The Supreme Court issues its landmark 'Miranda versus Arizona' decision, ruling that criminal suspects must be informed of their constitutional rights prior to questioning by police. (Source: New York Times)

June 13, 1971:  The “Pentagon Papers” are excerpted in the New York Times, giving details of U.S. involvement in Vietnam from the end of World War II to 1968. After the third installment, the Nixon Administration won a restraining order from a judge, the first prior restraint against newspaper publication ever granted to the federal government. (Source:  perspicuity

Wise Words

“Religion is essentially the art and the theory of the remaking of man. Man is not a finished creation.”

-- Edmund Burke (Source:  Brainy Quote

Campaign Tips

Interview Techniques

Don't be afraid to reframe questions. Almost any question, whether from a reporter or an audience member, can be reframed to make a point you want to make or to reduce the impact of a hard-hitting inquiry. But reframing must be done skillfully so you don’t appear to be avoiding the question. This is especially true during public debates. Good reframing will clarify the question, perhaps in a way more favorable to your position, but will not leave the candidate looking evasive or deceptive.

National Politics

Best Stories From …
-- Washington Post: "For the first time in five years, President Bush [was set to] attend the Senate Republicans' weekly policy lunch [Tuesday] as he pushes to revive his moribund overhaul of the nation's immigration laws. But even before he set foot in the Capitol, several Republican senators issued a terse warning [Monday]: Don't expect much. In the days after the broad compromise on immigration collapsed on Thursday, opposition, if anything, appears to have hardened among some senators who had once been willing to consider the deal. The bill's vociferous critics have also had a long weekend to throw dirt on its grave."

-- Los Angeles Times: Columnist Jonah Goldberg: "Here's a good question for you: Why have public schools at all? OK, cue the marching music. We need public schools because blah blah blah and yada yada yada. We could say blah is common culture and yada is the government's interest in promoting the general welfare. Or that children are the future. And a mind is a terrible thing to waste. Because we can't leave any child behind. The problem with all these bromides is that they leave out the simple fact that one of the surest ways to leave a kid 'behind' is to hand him over to the government. Americans want universal education, just as they want universally safe food. But nobody believes that the government should run 90% of the restaurants, farms and supermarkets. Why should it run 90% of the schools -- particularly when it gets terrible results?"

-- The Politico: Columnist Frank J. Donatelli"It is the worst of times for Republicans. President George W. Bush's approval ratings barely top 30 percent. Democrats have opened up as much as a 15-point lead in party identification ... Key issues such as immigration and Iraq are causing major fissures in the Republican coalition. ... History also tells us that 2008 should be a Democratic year. Third terms for the in-party in power are notoriously difficult to win. ... And yet, there are signs of hope in the gloom enveloping Republicans. There are several ways that the GOP might still mount a comeback and win the White House in 2008" (see also related Peter Beinart column).

-- The Economist: Editorial: "Roughly half a year after the Democrats seized Congress, nobody could deny that politics has grown more interesting. Judging from the newspapers today it is Capitol Hill, not the White House, where the action is in Washington, DC. ... And yet the past six months has also shown how painfully blocked-up America's checks-and-balances system can be. For all of the attention-grabbing activity, nothing concrete has yet been achieved."

Lighter Side

“The only thing which saves us from bureaucracy is its inefficiency.”

-- Eugene McCarthy     

“A patriot must always be ready to defend his country against his government.”

-- Edward Abbey

“We hang the petty thieves and appoint the great ones to public office.”

-- Aesop (Source: Humorous T-Shirts)

 

 

Wednesday
June 13, 2007


Utah in the National News   

Denver Post: "Economic opportunities are increasingly coming at altitude. Six of the nation's 10 fastest-growing state economies last year were located in the Mountain West, including Colorado's, according to the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis. Idaho and Utah were the fastest growers, experiencing inflation-adjusted economic-growth rates above 7 percent, more than double the U.S. average of 3.4 percent. 'The Rocky Mountain region has been leading the nation for about three years in overall performance,' said Jeff Thredgold, an economist with Vectra Bank Colorado" (see also related Associated Press story).

Christian Science Monitor: "In a rare move, a state attorney general plans to begin notifying thousands of residents whom it suspects have had their Social Security numbers misused by undocumented job applicants. This week, Utah's top law enforcement office will send out a first batch of letters based on data collected for state public-assistance programs. It is sending only 100 letters for now -- out of a potential 20,000 -- for fear of being overwhelmed by upset citizens seeking help."

Mitt Romney Watch

WMUR/CNN: "A new poll shows that former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney has surged ahead of the pack in New Hampshire in the Republican presidential primary race. The WMUR-CNN poll of 304 likely Republican voters shows Romney with 28 percent of the vote, an improvement from 17 percent in April. Rudy Giuliani and John McCain dropped to 20 percent each, down from 29 percent each in April" (for more on Romney, see Alex Spillius column).


Local Headlines

Salt Lake Tribune

- Humans causing warming, guvs told

- Utah employers in a tight spot

- Utah No. 1 in graduation

- Need a smoke? Take it . . . south

- Paul Rolly: Hey, guv, better late than never

- Rocky nearly in City Hall fist fight

- SLC Council passes green, lean budget

- Davis County to vote on added sales tax

- Jordan to sell $196M in bonds

- Split projections alarm Granite schools board

- Medicare cuts could hit seniors hard

- Red flag raised over ID theft

- Utah fuel prices down a bit from record high

- Editorial: Recreation balance: Garfield County is biased in favor of ATVs

Standard-Examiner

- Experts: Utah workforce will stay strong

- Op-ed: Many conservatives ignore conservative principles in solving environmental pollution

- Editorial: Thank you, Supremes

Park Record

- Tentative teacher contract reached

St. George Spectrum

- SkyWest lone bidder for service

- County gets input on proposed fee hikes

- Op-ed: Let's take charge of our future

- Editorial: Need for federal shield law

Daily Herald

- Permit plan proposed for parking south of BYU

- Charters scramble to be ready

- Editorial: Utah issues at a glance

Logan Herald Journal

- Rocky, Dell Loy nearly rumble

KCPW

- Sports Complex Price Tag Rises, Mayor Says Soccer Fans Need to Raise $

- Utah Doctors Cry Foul at Proposed Medicare Cuts

- Thousands of Utahns at Risk for SS# Fraud

- Utah HS Grad Rates Top in Nation

- Construction Remains Driving Force of Utah Economy

Tooele Transcript Bulletin

- Stansbury Park township drive stalls

- 1000 North road project moving ahead

Davis County Clipper

- Supreme Court decision lauded

- State funds are likely for election

- Farmington budget talk scheduled for next week

- Beattie privileged to live in Davis County

- Party Lines: Has Rocky gone too far with Sky Bridge?

Deseret Morning News

- Gas prices dip in U.S. but edge up in Utah

- Utah job growth stays strong

- Agency warns of potential child-ID thefts

- Rocky, builder cross swords

- Provo parking plan costly in first year

- A Lindon police split?

- Jordan District tops U.S. in graduation rate

- Salt Lake City Council adopts $202 million budget

- Highlights of the 2007-08 budget the City Council signed off on

- Zoo offers voters deal on bond OK

- Davis OKs vote on sales-tax hike

- Hatch touts tax incentive measure to expand oil refineries

- Davis bans smoking in outdoor areas

- 18,000 Rotarians may attend Salt Lake convention

- Editorial: Gonzales should resign


Political Calendar

Please submit calendar items to Daily@UtahPolicy.com

- June 13: Governor Huntsman to give welcoming remarks at the United Way Synergy Summit, 8 a.m., Utah Cultural Celebration Center, 1355 West 3100 South, West Valley City.
- June 13: Education Committee and Subcommittee meetings, 8 a.m., Granite School District Central Office. See Legislative calendar for details.
- June 13: KCPW Intelligence Squared debate "Freedom of Expression Must Include the License to Offend," 10 a.m., KCPW 88.3 FM. For more info visit http://www.intelligencesquaredus.org.
- June 13: RadioWest on KUER FM 90: "Oil on the Brain," 11 a.m. and 7 p.m. The nozzle at your local gas station doesn't just connect you to the pump - it connects you to the world at the other end of the pipe. Journalist Lisa Margonelli set out to explore that world, and she explains why Utah's $3.21 gasoline may actually be ridiculously cheap given the impacts of this complicated, global industry.
- June 13: Governor Huntsman to give opening remarks at Western Regional Trustee Symposium, 11:15 a.m., Grand Summit Resort Hotel & Conference Center, The Canyons.
- June 13: Governor Huntsman to tour the Legacy Parkway Project, 1:45 p.m.
- June 14: 2007 Sutherland Transcend Series, Session Three: “Civility in our Culture and Politics.” Half-day seminar, 8:30 a.m. to 1:00 p.m., includes breakfast and lunch. Facilitator is Mr. Paul Mero, president of the Sutherland Institute. All participants will receive a copy of Civility: Manners, Morals, and the Etiquette of Democracy, by Yale law professor Stephen L. Carter. To register, call 801-355-1272, or email si@sutherlandinstitute.org.

- See the entire calendar


Elected Officials Birthday List


Utah Policy Daily is a service
of Utah Policy.com

Publisher: LaVarr Webb
Editor: Paul Hollingshead
News: Golden Webb
Calendar and Subscriptions: Luci Hollingshead

 

Utah Policy Daily
Crandall Building, Suite 300
10 West 100 South
Salt Lake City UT 84101
801.537.0900 Office
801.537.0901 Fax

 

Special E-Mail Messages: Utah Policy Daily may send subscribers e-mails with information about new features, special offers, or messages on public policy issues from clients and advertisers. If you do not wish to ever receive these e-mails, please let us know by e-mail at daily@utahpolicy.com.




 

 

 


Feature Story


MVC and Air Pollution Concerns

By LaVarr Webb

The Sierra Club is mounting an attack on the Mountain View Corridor, arguing it shouldn’t be built until mass transit, such as light rail, is provided along the corridor.

Its latest tactic is to claim that the highway will be unhealthy for children in nearby schools (See Tribune story).

 

Volunteers plan to go door-to-door in certain neighborhoods, telling residents that the highway will pollute the air and endanger their health.

The long-range plan for the corridor does include mass transit, but not immediately. The obvious reason that UDOT, Wasatch Front Regional Council, Utah Transit Authority, etc., did not propose mass transit ahead of the highway is that ridership would initially be too low to justify the investment. As the population booms along the corridor over the next 20 or 30 years, mass transit will be developed to meet the needs. But the highway is clearly needed first, especially because it will accommodate truck traffic and will reduce congestion on other routes, such as I-15.

I’m an avid supporter of mass transit, as is the Sierra Club, but the best way to kill public transit such as light rail is to build a line that isn’t cost-effective. The Legislature isn’t going to stand for wasteful spending on mass transit.

Meanwhile, the Sierra Club’s concern about unhealthy air around major highways is well-taken, but it’s not a strong enough reason to shut down the highway. Living in modern society entails some risk, and we need to apply a bit of logic and reason before taking drastic action.

A few thoughts:  

-- The worst automobile pollution occurs when cars are in gridlock, pumping out fumes while at a standstill on narrow streets and on I-15, I-215 and Bangerter Highway. The Mountain View Corridor will help alleviate gridlock valley-wide and especially in the western valley areas.

-- The western part of the valley is going to grow dramatically, no matter what. To not provide the necessary transportation infrastructure would be disastrous and dangerous. Highway safety must be considered along with pollution concerns.

-- We should all be concerned about air pollution. But how many millions of children have grown up close to a major highway? (I, myself, grew up next to a major freeway.) Remember that despite the fact that we are more urbanized than ever and have more automobile traffic than ever, our health is better, and we live longer and better than ever before. Hundreds of schools around the state are built close to major highways. The cost of rerouting highways to avoid schools would be astronomical.

-- If we don’t provide necessary transportation infrastructure, the western part of the valley essentially shuts down, which severely damages our economy.

-- Mountain View Corridor will benefit the entire valley, not just the west side. It will take traffic off I-15. It will spark development and jobs on the west side so people won’t need to travel so far to work.

There are lots of things to worry about in life. But it’s important to keep a rational perspective. Shutting down a desperately-needed highway over air pollution concerns, thereby creating congestion and gridlock valleywide, isn’t a rational perspective.

 
 
 

On the Move

Links to the Week's Key Transportation News Stories

-- Editorial: Hands off UTA (Standard-Examiner).

-- Editorial: End new airport turf war (St. George Spectrum).

-- Logan airport terminal proposed (Logan Herald Journal).

-- Legacy Parkway Connector: 4 options (Davis County Clipper).

-- Editorial: Better bus service: It's time for UTA to live up to its promises (Salt Lake Tribune).

-- UDOT begins traffic study (Deseret Morning News).

-- Editorial: Transit first: Mountain View should be more than a highway (Salt Lake Tribune).

-- MAG issues support for freeway on 2100 North (Daily Herald).

-- Resolution OK'd on Utah County road connection (Deseret Morning News).

-- Davis voters may decide fate of plan to boost sales tax ¼% (Morning News).


HNTB is a multidisciplinary firm known and respected for our work in transportation, bridges, aviation, architecture, urban design and planning, environmental engineering, water and construction services. We serve our clients with integrity, technical excellence and a commitment to performance— providing quality work, on time, on budget and to the client's satisfaction.

At HNTB, we're committed to providing an environment where our people can be successful, and where they can create infrastructure that exceeds the expectations of our clients and the communities they serve. Through exceptional service and a shared vision, we create public infrastructure that unites, enriches and inspires.

Visit HNTB's website here.



Utah Transportation Watch is a service of Utah Policy.com