Today's political briefing: Key developments
and analysis for Utah policymakers
Subscribe or Unsubscribe

Message Center

Announcements, Advertisements, Advertorials, and Sponsored Articles

Transportation Watch

Time to Boost the Gas Tax

Despite heroic funding efforts by the Legislature, the state is billions of dollars behind in highway funding. The best short-term, partial solution is to boost the gas tax and/or index it or turn it into a sales tax.

The chance of the Legislature approving such a tax boost in the 2008 election-year session is pretty slim. But a number of proposals are on the table that make sense and would clearly be palatable to the public, even in an election year. The Utah Taxpayers Association, for example, supports a gas tax boost, but it would be offset by an income tax cut.

There is obviously an excellent case to be made for higher gas taxes. Every year, the state gas tax, in terms of inflation-adjusted dollars, declines. Utahns, in effect, have been getting a gas tax cut every year for the last several years. Other taxes, such as income, property and sales, rise with inflation, higher incomes and higher property values. We don’t call it a tax increase as revenues from those taxes go up because the tax rates (for the most part) stay the same. (Read entire essay below)



 

News Highlights

First in a seven-part series, the Deseret Morning News profiles SLC mayoral candidate Ralph Becker.

Utah has rivers that could be designated as wild and scenic, but some rural counties have fought to limit the number of streams so designated (Salt Lake Tribune).

Quote of the Day

"What's going to make you any more effectual, beyond all the platitudes and the stuff we're used to hearing?"

-- BYU film student Zach Kempf, asking the first question to Democratic presidential candidates in the YouTube debate (Tribune).


Wednesday Buzz
Written by LaVarr Webb & Associates

Hatch: Give House Seat to DC

Sen. Orrin Hatch joins a prominent group of civil rights advocates at a press conference to push for the passage of the DC Voting Rights Act, which would give the District of Columbia a full House seat and add a fourth congressional seat for Utah (see press release); the Senate passes the Higher Education Access Act of 2007, which Hatch "helped develop and shepherd through the Senate as a member of the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee" and which "will help make college more affordable for Americans struggling to obtain advanced education" (press release).

Regional Politics

Candidates Ignoring West?

Denver Post: "This is supposed to be the presidential election that puts the Rocky Mountain West on the political map. So far, though, the hype has been more talk than walk. Lacking the deep pockets found in California and on the East Coast, the national prominence of the two big primary states, Iowa and New Hampshire, and the electoral heft of Florida, the Interior West has not exactly been a revolving door for candidates in the past few months."

Today in Political History

July 25, 1905: U.S. interests begin construction of the Panama Canal.

July 25, 1949:  The North Atlantic Treaty (NATO) is formally ratified by President Harry Truman in a Cabinet Room signing ceremony. (Source:  Perspicuity

Wise Words

“If men of wisdom and knowledge, of moderation and temperance, of patience, fortitude and perseverance, of sobriety and true republican simplicity of manners, of zeal for the honour of the Supreme Being and the welfare of the commonwealth; if men possessed of these other excellent qualities are chosen to fill the seats of government, we may expect that our affairs will rest on a solid and permanent foundation.”

-- Samuel Adams, letter to Elbridge Gerry (Source:  Patriot Post

Communications Tip

Use News Media Strategically

By Mark Montini

Campaigns, organizations, and businesses can avoid most of the so-called “media bias” if they take time to decide why they want media coverage in the first place. In other words, you need to have a clear strategic plan for your media relations BEFORE you start getting coverage.

How can media help you implement that plan? This one, simple, question will do more to change your perspective on “media bias” than just about anything else. Here are a few examples:

Let’s say you’re a conservative candidate who decides that you’re going to use media coverage for fundraising. Does a “biased” article attacking you in the local liberal newspaper really hurt you? I would argue that it doesn’t. After all, the people who are most likely to donate to your campaign would probably question your conservative credentials if the liberal newspaper was saying good things about you. Turn the coverage into a fundraising letter. Use it as an example of how you stand up for your principles and how the establishment is working to stop you. Then, tell the donors how they can join your fight for your principles by helping you fight the establishment.

On that same note, if you “recycle” that “biased” piece to get more coverage from friendly-media outlets that reach your donors, it could actually help your campaign even more. (Source:  Campaign Hot Tips

National Politics

Best Stories From . . .

-- Washington Post: "Democratic presidential candidates shared the spotlight Monday night with ordinary citizens from around the country in a two-hour debate that featured sharp and sometimes witty video questions and often equally sharp exchanges among the candidates on issues ranging from Iraq and health care to whether any of them can fix a broken political system."

-- Los Angeles Times: "With the 2008 presidential campaign generating intense interest, candidates are finding that small donations are anything but chump change. They are raising unprecedented amounts in small sums, employing the Internet and traditional direct-mail and telemarketing techniques, and holding low-budget fundraising rallies."

-- Wall Street Journal: "For friends and foes of Sen. John McCain, a mystery lingers nearly two weeks after his campaign shake-up: Given the budgetary crisis that triggered the upheaval, why did he choose the adviser formerly most responsible for campaign finances to right the ship?"

-- New York Magazine: "Fred Thompson bills himself as a true southern conservative and a plain-ol’-folks regular guy. But is he just playing a part?"

Lighter Side

Favorite Headlines

(Source: James Taranto’s Best of the Web on OpinionJournal.com)

How'd They Know Which Was Which?
"Shark Attacks Lawyer Off Oahu"--headline, Seattle Times, July 22

Almost Certainly Money
"What Do Lamar County Schools Spend?"--headline, Paris (Texas) News, July 23

The Rest of Us Face Eternity
"Driver Faces 7 Years in Death"--headline, Gloucester County (N.J.) Times, July 24

They Were Growing Daisies
"Deceased Farmers Got USDA Payments"--headline, Washington Post,

 

 

Wednesday
July 25, 2007


Utah in the National News   

New York Times story spotlights Utah's newest town, Bryce Canyon City, which "consists solely of the 2,300-acre [Ruby's Inn] resort, including its two hotels, souvenir-filled gift shops, a rodeo arena, restaurants, gas stations, a grocery store and areas for campers and recreational vehicles." (See also related Associated Press story).


Local Headlines

Salt Lake Tribune

- 4th-seat friends rush to turn up heat on Senate

- River act heading to murky waters

- Kid-friendly: Utah near top

- Utahns take part in first-ever YouTube debate

- Kennecott's copper donation will boost memorial

- Nearer to a day they'll be citizens

- Editorial: Special needs: We need accountability for recipients

Park Record

- Ranchers: a dying breed

KCPW

- Utah Film Incentives Not Sufficient to Compete in Hollywood?

Tooele Transcript Bulletin

- Editorial: When places grow too fast, choices can get lost

Davis County Clipper

- UTOPIA set to start work in Centerville

- Knight ready to run for Bountiful City Council

- Davis projects top new transport list

- Bountiful man re-elected to Democrat post

- Davis residents mixed in support for Romney

- Aging issues tackled at national county convention

- Three counties to boost economic growth together

- County jobless rate stays under nation's

- Republican: Are needy children at core of CHIP debate?

- Democrat: Are needy children at core of CHIP debate?

Daily Herald

- PG Council replacement

Deseret Morning News

- Maybe the votes for a 4th Utah seat

- Demo Becker boasts a wealth of experience

- Ralph Becker bio

- Indians finding a voice in San Juan

- Legislators looking at how cities are run

- Warming a top issue in 2nd District

- Bennett hails Pioneer Day in Senate speech

- Editorial: Keep young people sober


Political Calendar

Please submit calendar items to Daily@UtahPolicy.com

- July 25-27: Lieutenant Governor Herbert to attend National Lieutenant Governor's Association, Williamsburg, Virginia.
- July 25: RadioWest on KUER FM 90: "White Light/Black Rain," 11 a.m. and 7 p.m. Oscar-winning filmmaker Steven Okazaki has created a powerful documentary on the story of the A-bomb - not from the perspective of politicians and historians - but in the words of the people who have lived more than 60 years with its consequences.
- July 25: Governor Huntsman to attend the Odyssey House Tour, 3:15 p.m., 600 East 200 South, Salt Lake City.
- July 26: Salt Lake County Libertarian Party Meeting, 7 p.m., Mo's Neighborhood Grill, 358 South West Temple, Salt Lake City. For more information, visit LPUtah.org.
- July 31: Utah International Trade Commission, 10 a.m., room W020.
- Aug 1: Financial reporting deadline for Salt Lake City candidates
- Aug 1: Lincoln Club meeting with Lt. Governor Herbert, 7 p.m., 15th Floor of Wells Fargo Building. For info contact Duane Millard at 801-706-5082 or email Jeremy Roberts at jeroberts@storesonline.com.
- Aug 1: White City Community Council meeting, 7 p.m., Eastmont Middle School, 10100 S 1300 E, Room 105, Sandy.
- Aug 7: Utah for Richardson Meeting, 7 p.m., Conference Room D, Salt Lake City Library, 210 East 400 South. The group is an organization of Utahns who support the candidacy of Governor Bill Richardson for President of the United States. The meeting is open to the media and all interested community members. RSVP to Utah for Richardson State Director Aaron Thompson at dipl0mac03@yahoo.com.
- Aug 16:
Utah Fund of Funds: Progress and Benefits Luncheon, 11:30 a.m. to 1 p.m., The Barn at Thanksgiving Point, Lehi. Sponsored by MountainWest Capital Network (MWCN), Utah Technology Council (UTC), Utah Valley Entrepreneurial Forum (UVEF), Wayne Brown Institute (WBI). To RSVP or for more info, contact Jeremy Neilson at

801-521-3072 or Jeremy@UtahFoF.com.
- Aug 22: Utah Republican Party Ronald Reagan Club meeting with the new State Party Chairman, Governor and other legislators, 6 p.m. New members are welcome to join by calling the party headquarters at 801-533-9777.
- Aug 23: Reagan Day Dinner for Salt Lake County Republican legislators, 7 p.m., Little America Hotel, Salt Lake City. For table sponsorship info, contact Jeremy Roberts at 801-867-3866 or email jeremy@finishfirst.org.
- Aug 24: Utah Republican Party Golf Tournament, 8 a.m., Thanksgiving Point. For more information, contact the state party headquarters at 801-533-9777.
- Sept 6: Annual Judgesrun Foundation Charity Golf Tournament, 8 a.m. shotgun start, Homestead, Midway. Lunch buffet at 1 p.m., awards and conclusion at 3 p.m. Four person scramble, register as an individual or a team. For more info contact Samantha at 801-364-8300 or click here.
- Sept 10: Rob Bishop Golf Tournament, 8 a.m. shotgun start, Mountain Dell Golf Course. Hole sponsors and foursomes are still available.  Please call Tara Tanner 801-575-6355 for more information.

- See the entire calendar


Elected Officials Birthday List


Utah Policy Daily is a service
of Utah Policy.com

Publisher: LaVarr Webb
Editor: Paul Hollingshead
News: Golden Webb
Calendar and Subscriptions: Luci Hollingshead

 

Utah Policy Daily
Crandall Building, Suite 300
10 West 100 South
Salt Lake City UT 84101
801.537.0900 Office
801.537.0901 Fax

 

Special E-Mail Messages: Utah Policy Daily may send subscribers e-mails with information about new features, special offers, or messages on public policy issues from clients and advertisers. If you do not wish to ever receive these e-mails, please let us know by e-mail at daily@utahpolicy.com.




 

 

 


Feature Story


Time to Boost the Gas Tax

By LaVarr Webb

The Salt Lake Tribune endorsed raising the state gas tax in a Tuesday editorial. On Sunday, a Deseret Morning News editorial called for more funding for critical highway needs.

Despite heroic funding efforts by the Legislature, the state is billions of dollars behind in highway funding. The best short-term, partial solution is to boost the gas tax and/or index it or turn it into a sales tax.

The chance of the Legislature approving such a tax boost in the 2008 election-year session is pretty slim. But a number of proposals are on the table that make sense and would clearly be palatable to the public, even in an election year. The Utah Taxpayers Association, for example, supports a gas tax boost, but it would be offset by an income tax cut.

There is obviously an excellent case to be made for higher gas taxes. Every year, the state gas tax, in terms of inflation-adjusted dollars, declines. Utahns, in effect, have been getting a gas tax cut every year for the last several years. Other taxes, such as income, property and sales, rise with inflation, higher incomes and higher property values. We don’t call it a tax increase as revenues from those taxes go up because the tax rates (for the most part) stay the same.

But the gas tax, because it is cents per gallon instead of a percentage of the price, has no ability to rise with the economy. Thus, despite huge population increases and more gasoline being purchased, the gas tax has declined dramatically on a percentage basis as a source of highway funding, even in the face of enormous unfunded highway needs.

Tax boosts for special purposes need to be put in the context of the overall state tax burden and tax history. While Utah overall has relatively high taxes (mostly because of the large education burden resulting from large families), state lawmakers have cut billions of dollars in taxes cumulatively over the last several years. The only significant tax increases have come at the local level where citizens, in most cases, have voted to increase taxes on themselves (such as school bonds, transit taxes, RAP taxes, etc.)

I believe the vast majority of voters are smart enough to see that, overall, the trend in Utah has been tax-cutting, not tax-increasing. And I believe voters understand it sometimes makes sense to shuffle taxes to meet certain needs, such as increasing gas taxes while offsetting it with other tax cuts. Voters won’t punish lawmakers who support smart tax policy and take care of Utah’s crucial infrastructure needs.

 
 

On the Move

Links to the Week's Key Transportation News Stories

-- Council, Billings back a belt loop (Deseret Morning News).

-- UTA plans to ask for tax hike in Tooele and Grantsville (Tooele Transcript Bulletin).

-- Public hearing set on Legacy connection (Davis County Clipper).

-- UTA Front Runner trains to begin tests next month (Davis County Clipper).

-- Utah may hike gas tax to fund work on roads (Deseret Morning News).

-- Lawmaker: Fuel tax inadequate (Salt Lake Tribune).

-- Provo approves plan to build road (Tribune).

-- Consultant urges area rail service expansion (Logan Herald Journal).

-- Bob Bernick Jr.: Tax hikes and election years just don't go together (Deseret Morning News).

-- Highway projects part of plan (St. George Spectrum).

-- Editorial: Highway needs require money (Deseret Morning News).

-- Editorial: To build new roads, fuels tax must be hiked (Salt Lake Tribune).


HNTB is a multidisciplinary firm known and respected for our work in transportation, bridges, aviation, architecture, urban design and planning, environmental engineering, water and construction services. We serve our clients with integrity, technical excellence and a commitment to performance— providing quality work, on time, on budget and to the client's satisfaction.

At HNTB, we're committed to providing an environment where our people can be successful, and where they can create infrastructure that exceeds the expectations of our clients and the communities they serve. Through exceptional service and a shared vision, we create public infrastructure that unites, enriches and inspires.

Visit HNTB's website here.



Utah Transportation Watch is a service of Utah Policy.com