Utah Republicans Forget the Past While Cheering Ryan
by Bob Bernick
08/30/2012 | 1312 views | 1 1 comments | 5 5 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Bob Bernick, Utah Policy Contributing Editor
Bob Bernick, Utah Policy Contributing Editor
slideshow
GOP Vice President nominee Rep. Paul Ryan gave an inspiring speech Wednesday night as the delegates cheered at times and booed when called for.

CNN several times cut to floor shots of the Utah delegation, whose pro-Mitt Romney supporters were seen cheering Ryan on.

That’s all well and good. And it’s what national delegates are supposed to do.

But among those cheering delegates were a number of GOP Utah legislators, and several of their leaders.

As the crowd cheered Ryan when he criticized President Barack Obama’s $800 billion stimulus package – and as those Utah GOP delegates cheered as well – one has to wonder if they have forgotten just how much they appreciated (maybe even loved) the hundreds of millions of dollars that came to the Utah state government in 2009 and 2010.

It was those millions of federal dollars that allowed the GOP-controlled Legislature and Gov. Gary Herbert (cheering down on that convention floor Wednesday night) to keep from laying of hundreds of state workers and trim back needed programs.

I recall sitting in an open Utah House GOP caucus at the end of one of those general sessions and – perhaps a bit sheepishly – several fiscal conservatives asked if there was any more federal stimulus money coming to the state, so they could balance the budget without having to cut any more.

Out of one side of their mouths they condemned Obama’s economic policies, while out of the other side they asked if there was more.

That is understandable. It’s human, if not only partisan.

And faced with the tough decisions Utah lawmakers had to make in those days, the federal money was welcomed.

Along with a forward-looking Rainy Day Fund (which, by the way, was set up in part by one of Utah’s more moderate GOP lawmakers – former Utah House Majority Leader, Lt. Gov. and Gov. Olene Walker), with good fiscal management from years of Republican legislative leadership, and responsible GOP governors, Utah government was well placed to weather the Great Recession.

But without the federal money so condemned by Ryan Wednesday night – and cheered by the Utah GOP delegation – Utahns would have had to suffer a lot more pain over the last four years.

And sometimes, during fine national convention speeches, the facts should be remembered, also.
Comments
(1)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
|
August 30, 2012
I don't agree with Mr. Bernick's argument that it's hypocritical to take the stimulus money but still disagree with the stimulus. His premise is similar the attacks that Democrats have made in recent weeks against Paul Ryan for accepting his father's social security survivor benefits while trying to reform social security. There's nothing hypocritical about using the system as it exists while arguing at the same time that there is a better way. Utah's legislators rightfully took full advantage of the stimulus while arguing that the stimulus was a bad policy.
today's headlines
Local Headlines
May 17, 2013 | 17234 views | 0 0 comments | 1 1 recommendations | email to a friend | print

Salt Lake Tribune

Op-ed: Swallow and the Legislature

Editorial: The right decision: Herbert should stick to his guns

Suit: Make EPA force Utah to cut winter pollution

Hatch wants IRS probe to expand, include Freedom Path

Green activists, neighbors blast new West Davis freeway plan

Hatch calls for investigation of Obamacare funding

Thousands of Utahns face Defense Department furloughs

Utah charter schools under new performance scrutiny

Midvale's streetlight project stalls over flawed bid process

Deseret News

Matthew Sanders: Imploding trust in America's institutions

Editorial: Habits die hard

Utah lawmakers look to regulate child access to e-cigarettes

Oil, gas wells to move closer to Duchesne County homes

Health care reform about to 'get real' for Utahns

New poll shows GOP caucus attendees support changes to nomination system

2 county attorneys investigating Swallow, Utah Attorney General's office

West Davis Corridor project unveiled amid criticism

Elder Oaks promotes strengthening the free exercise of religion

Other

Heidi Toth: Squandering the public trust (Daily Herald)

RedBlue: Can Barack Obama survive scandals? (Daily Herald)

Op-ed: The gigabit community (Standard-Examiner)

Editorial: Don't make AG an appointment (Standard-Examiner)

UDOT releases DEIS, recommendation for Legacy extension (Standard-Examiner)

Ogden School Board faces anger over cutbacks (Standard-Examiner)

Will Swallow make appearance at the state GOP convention? (Standard-Examiner)

Hatch pushes for expanded probe into IRS actions (Standard-Examiner)

Comments
(0)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
No Comments Yet
Comments
(0)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
No Comments Yet
Comments
(0)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
No Comments Yet
utah tweets
RSS Feeds
Utah policy stories feed
Policy buzz feed
Daily news highlights feed
Washington watch feed

With support from PinPointInternetMarketing.com